This is really fascinating stuff. It explains a lot of things I’ve noticed about other people in my life I’ve known who are poor readers. I’ve always been a great reader for as long as I can remember, had parents who helped teach me to read and read with me and all that which can help a lot. The “incorrect” way that school are teaching to kids is to basically guess what words means instead of trying to memorize the phonetic pronunciation of individual words to commit them to memory. I remember in high school there being activities where we would go around the room and different students would read different parts of like a book or textbook out loud. And as someone lucky enough to have learned how to read well, I was always flabbergasted when I would hear some people read. I’d be reading along in the book and thinking “what the fuck, they’re saying words that aren’t even on this page. How is this even possible to mess up this badly that you’re not just mispronouncing words you’re literally inserting words out of nowhere” and the research would suggest that’s its because they were literally just reading the first part of the word and guessing the rest of it. No wonder some people hate reading it’s basically playing a guessing game 😳
When our kids were 7th and 8th grade my wife subbed at the school for a while. She worked a number of days at their grade level and a grade or 2 higher.
What she saw was very similar.
Our kids were getting straight As. No exaggeration. Yet they were having trouble doing homework consisting of math problems they struggled with 2 years prior.
They weren’t being taught anything, they were being prepped for the standardized tests given at the end of the year. Also, any tests and quizzes throughout the year they were given multiple tries to retake, and that explains the straight As.
That’s when we pulled them out and began homeschooling. No regerts.
We’ve been homeschooling since the pandemic started but my kids said they want to go back to school this year, so we’re letting them go back. I’ve told them that I’ll be with them, though, if they change their minds. I have years of experience as a teacher overseas and I’ve also subbed in local school districts. I didn’t encounter issues with reading pre-pandemic but I’m pretty sure now that after three years of doing commie homeschool, my kids are the ones who should be teaching social studies rather than learning from the white liberals whose only job is to obscure the past and confuse the young. We also tutored the fuck out of our older kid who was having issues with math. Thanks to doing that with khan academy, he no longer has those issues, and both of our kids are now interested in coding (which isn’t offered for kids their age at their school).
We have had a similar problem with maths here in the UK. They keep constantly changing the curriculum and there is no real standard, none of it really seems to work and as a result we’ve had the lowest rates of kids becoming engineers and scientists for years.
That reddit thread is full of people (hopefully not teachers) insisting that it’s actually a parent’s job to teach their children to read. Ignoring the ‘fuck poor or undereducated parents’ attitude on display, I have to ask, what’s the point of early education then? My first few years of school were all about literacy and numeracy skills. If these aren’t the responsibility of the education system at that age, then what on earth is? I guess it’s just daycare to these people…
While parents aren’t the people solely responsible for their childrens education, it is striking to me how things have changed recently.
The kids coming in are less well-equpped than they used to be. Not potty trained, can’t tie their shoes, can’t tell the time. Like it used to be a few kids that had an issue or two, but now it’s a bunch with a lot of issues.
Things have gotten worse recently. Parents aren’t as able to help their children as they used to be. This does increase the work load for teachers.
podcasts.google.com
Hot