I try not to see it as a list clearing situation. For me that just stresses me out with unnecesary "I'll never be able to play everything" FOMO. I see my library and wishlist as more a hat with a bunch of scraps of paper with game names. And I'll just start something up randomly and just see where it takes me.
It sounds cringy lmao, but I've found some genuinely amazing games and genres I never initially thought I'd be into