rysiek, (edited )
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

FuckFuckNo. 🤦‍♀️

I just want a search engine that works. I have zero need for a godawful "AI" hallucinating mansplainer in my results. Just… no.

Time to move off of DDG. What else is out there?

Edit: yes, it seems to be for real:
https://www.reddit.com/r/duckduckgo/comments/1adxgy4/give_duckduckgo_ai_chat_a_spin/

#DuckDuckGo #AI

Dianora,
@Dianora@ottawa.place avatar

@rysiek Oh no :-( Time to bring back webrings...

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@Dianora 💯

cyrus,
@cyrus@wetdry.world avatar

@rysiek @Mojeek is often my go-to, but many people dislike it due to how different the search results are.

You may be interested in aggregating results using SearxNG, maybe? https://searx.space

Samlane86,

@cyrus @rysiek @Mojeek I'll throw in another vote for SearxNG. Been using it as my default for a bit now and an usually happy with the results. StartPage used to be my default now I only use it as a back up option.

rail_,
@rail_@bark.lgbt avatar

@rysiek Qwant and Startpage I guess

wojciech_space,
@wojciech_space@pol.social avatar
falcon,
@falcon@mastodon.falconk.rocks avatar

@rysiek I am reminded of when, against all feedback and better judgement, phone manufacturers universally decided to stop building headphone jacks and physical buttons.

aral,
@aral@mastodon.ar.al avatar

@rysiek @alex Ah, damn. T’was bound to happen. They’re VC-funded. Let the enshittification begin!

share_sun,
@share_sun@mastodon.social avatar

@rysiek what about arc?

noodlejetski,
@noodlejetski@masto.ai avatar

@share_sun @rysiek you mean the AI-powered iOS-only app that uses AI to display summaries instead of actual websites? pretty sure it's AI-based.

nus,
@nus@mstdn.social avatar

@rysiek is this a genuine reason to leave? It's dumb, sure, but it's also sitting in a corner and can just be ignored or even hidden.

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@nus "don't worry about Tool A implementing the Torment Nexus, you can ignore it or turn it off for yourself in the settings." 🤷‍♀️

nus,
@nus@mstdn.social avatar

@rysiek I get that AI things are created unethically, but so is the computer you're replying on. What makes this uniquely worthy of condemning?

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@nus everyone gets to draw the line somewhere. I draw it there. You may draw it elsewhere.

enmodo,
@enmodo@mastodon.social avatar

@rysiek it's entirely within their raison d'etre to offer privacy preserving access to services they don't have themselves. Think of this as a VPN for AI access. I've used other search engines that did this for images and maps, at least as an alternative. If they do it then it avoids you being tempted to access them without privacy protections.

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@enmodo that's still buying into and supporting the hype train. And I ain't interested in that.

mcmenguc,
@mcmenguc@mstdn.social avatar

@rysiek their search results were starting to look more and more like google. Last couple of months the results were lousy and commercial. This explains it.

StillIRise1963,
@StillIRise1963@mastodon.world avatar

@rysiek Ugh. I just moved there.🙄

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@StillIRise1963 yeah, the whole search engines space is bad.

At this point there doesn't seem to be a decent search engine with no AI integration what-so-ever. Sigh.

ljrk,
@ljrk@todon.eu avatar

@rysiek +1 for stract, it's quite neat. That, plus searXNG and MetaGer are the ones I'm hopeful for.

danie10,
@danie10@mastodon.social avatar

@rysiek if they'd just called it a search "summary" no-one would have worried ;-)

1stAmendmentAbuser,

@rysiek I'd be down and like it a lot if they used an open-source uncensored AI for t5his, not the MS's garbage. Well, we'll wait and see how they're gonna deal with the backlash from the community

rysiek,
@rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

@1stAmendmentAbuser can you point me to an "open-source, uncensored AI" that is a model of the size needed for this kind of tasks, please?

Llama does not count, it's been trained at Facebook and nobody really knows what went into the training data.

silverwizard,

I don't even know where to go 😥 I'm so tired on the topic of AI @rysiek

bobjonkman,
@bobjonkman@mastodon.sdf.org avatar

@silverwizard
@rysiek

I've been using either @Mojeek or #StartPage on my browsers. Over the last two years of using #Mojeek it has become noticeably better, but not so much for StartPage...

silverwizard,

@bobjonkman @Mojeek @rysiek I just tried Mojeek and all of my results were AI generated SEO slop >.>

Mojeek,
@Mojeek@mastodon.social avatar

@silverwizard @bobjonkman @rysiek if you are able to send that into us with the submit feedback button then we can take a look.

shekinahcancook,
@shekinahcancook@babka.social avatar

@rysiek

is already pretty useless without boolean search options, and it also ignores dates. So if you're trying to search for something from 2014, you can't. Nor can you exclude all the stupid amazon or pinterest posts, etc. It's useless junk. And now it's useless junk with a heaping pike of garbage on top.

Flamekebab,
@Flamekebab@toot.wales avatar

@shekinahcancook @rysiek the lack of exclusion options shocked me. How does anyone find DDG useful without the option to filter stuff out?

shekinahcancook,
@shekinahcancook@babka.social avatar

@Flamekebab @rysiek

Exactly.

noodlejetski,
@noodlejetski@masto.ai avatar
noodlejetski,
@noodlejetski@masto.ai avatar

@rysiek goddammit, just when their results started being decent enough for me to not use !g or !s as a crutch! JUST LET ME FIND THINGS FFS

jeruyyap,
@jeruyyap@hachyderm.io avatar

@rysiek

I feel the question of "what else is there" depends on what you're actually looking for.

If you're just looking to use a large index while minimizing the data you're sending back, then DuckDuckGo still works for that. DuckDuckGo and Qwant use Bing's index, while Startpage uses Google's index, and any of those would work for that purpose.

If you're looking for a independent index for general use, Mojeek probably has the largest index that is not Google, Bing, or Yandex.

jeruyyap,
@jeruyyap@hachyderm.io avatar

@rysiek

Now if you're trying to avoid search engines that are into LLMs, then your options are going to depend on whether the index provider matters.

If only the service you are directly using matters, then you have plenty of options as there's seemingly endless search engines using Google or Bing (especially Bing).

If where the index comes from matters then you're pretty much out of large mainstream indexes and into small independent ones and a major change in search habits.

thomastospace,
@thomastospace@phpc.social avatar

@rysiek I use Kagi, it's paid (so no ads or user tracking needed). It has optional AI, but it's based on sources (and it will mention those, like Wikipedia does).

GossiTheDog,
@GossiTheDog@cyberplace.social avatar

deleted_by_author

  • Loading...
  • rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @GossiTheDog yeah, I'm aware. I would much prefer a search engine with decent results that is supported by paying customers.

    archliberal,
    @archliberal@mastodo.neoliber.al avatar

    deleted_by_author

  • Loading...
  • rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar
    jonyoder,
    @jonyoder@mstdn.social avatar

    @rysiek StartPage is pretty good

    djh,
    @djh@chaos.social avatar

    @rysiek Why not continue to use DDG but simply don't use the optional experimental functionality there?

    This would give them valuable feedback for what percentage of their user base is interested in this technology.

    From what I can see it's optional and an experiment, nothing they force on everyone?

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @djh the fact that they even consider investing time and effort into this is a huge red flag for me. I am not going to wait until that red flag materializes as something even worse.

    MotionToExtendDebate,

    @rysiek you don't have to use it if you don't want to. It only works if you tap on the 💬 icon. That doesn't make DuckDuckGo bad or bloated. And to be honest I prefer being able to use GPT without an account rather.

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @MotionToExtendDebate it's a huge red flag that they even consider implementing stuff like that.

    MotionToExtendDebate,

    @rysiek there are still plenty of other search engines that suit everyone's needs. Plus, privacy-aware people can now use AI at least anonymously. I haven't had any concerns with DDG and I've been using DDG and Brave Search, they are both good at different things. Hope that this new feature doesn't make people lose trust over DDG.

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @MotionToExtendDebate I don't want to "use AI anonymously". I want to not use tools that have this crap integrated in the first place, as a way of very intentionally not supporting the hype.

    berkes,
    @berkes@mastodon.nl avatar

    @rysiek How do you know it will be a "hallucinating mansplainer in my results" ?

    Why do you think it will?

    Jumping to conclusions and then getting angry at those conclusions is not a very good way to get through life....

    noodlejetski,
    @noodlejetski@masto.ai avatar

    @berkes @rysiek
    > Why do you think it will?

    hmmm, perhaps based on countless examples of bullshitting by the LLMs to date?

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @berkes I'm doing fine with going through life, thanks. And anything that touches ChatGPT or any other LLM in the context of a search product to me is super sus.

    There's ample evidence of LLM chatbots providing completely made up results. I am not going to wait until DDG decides it's "good enough" and integrates it more into their stuff.

    pa27,

    @rysiek It's just a desktop browser option to use a bot. Don't use it if you don't want to? It doesn't say it's related to search results, in the reddit link.

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @pa27 well it seems that there is some LLM shenanigans going on in the search results as well:
    https://mstdn.social/@xarvos@outerheaven.club/111126323556614433

    pa27,

    @rysiek Hmm.. Well that's crappy then. Having said that, I just tried a quick search and can't reproduce that result. Maybe different search terms. All the search engines are getting crappy one way or another. Back to books maybe!!!

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @pa27 blogrolls.

    Decentralize,
    @Decentralize@dt.gl avatar

    @rysiek and it's partnered with Leo from Brave? Horror

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @Decentralize wait, who's partnered with Leo from Brave?

    And who's "Leo from Brave"?

    Decentralize,
    @Decentralize@dt.gl avatar

    @rysiek leo is the Ai of Brave Brower, and someone earlier posted they partnered with duckduckgo. So it's not confirmed, but everything Ai doesn't need to be on my browser anyway

    rysiek,
    @rysiek@mstdn.social avatar

    @Decentralize ah, ugh

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • DuckDuckGo
  • DreamBathrooms
  • ngwrru68w68
  • cubers
  • magazineikmin
  • thenastyranch
  • rosin
  • khanakhh
  • InstantRegret
  • Youngstown
  • slotface
  • Durango
  • kavyap
  • mdbf
  • tacticalgear
  • JUstTest
  • osvaldo12
  • normalnudes
  • tester
  • cisconetworking
  • everett
  • GTA5RPClips
  • ethstaker
  • anitta
  • Leos
  • provamag3
  • modclub
  • megavids
  • lostlight
  • All magazines