Rules

1 | Be nice and constructive.

Be constructive; help people make their ideas better.
Write detailed comments instead of just saying, “It’s good,” or, “It’s bad.”
Report rude members to staff instead of trying to deal with them yourself.

Users found being overly rude, hateful, or destructive will be punished.

2 | Speak English.

This magazine's members and staff primarily speak English; please do so as well.
Consider using Google Translate if you can’t speak English.

Content posted in other languages will be removed. Users found continuously speaking other languages despite multiple warnings are at risk of punishment.

3 | Only post ideas for Minecraft.

Stay on topic; only post suggestions to vanilla Minecraft.
Don’t post bug reports or rants. Please go to Mojang’s official bug tracker to report bugs.
Don’t ask for suggestions for what to do in Minecraft. Consider !minecraft or many other related communities.
Posts asking questions to others or talking about the subreddit itself must use the appropriate flairs.

Posts that aren’t on topic will be removed. Misflaired posts will be flaired appropriately by staff.

4 | Be original and consult the FPS list.

Consult the Frequently Posted Suggestions list before posting. This contains suggestions that are posted often, and ideas on this list must be presented with an original twist.
Don’t repost suggestions from less than a month ago.
Don’t suggest features from mods, videos, other games, etc.
Don't ask the community to make your suggestion for you.

Posts deemed unoriginal or with content on the FPS list are at risk of removal.

5 | Don't include multiple independent ideas in one post.

To help ensure that voting is efficient and directed towards individual suggestions, don’t post suggestion lists.
A suggestion list is a post with multiple suggestions that are independent of each other and could reasonably be posted separately. Even if the ideas share the same theme, they must be dependent on each other to pass this rule.

Exceptions are made for especially high-quality posts.

Posts with multiple independent suggestions are at risk of removal.

6 | Be concise but specific.

Make sure your idea is in the description, not the title. Regardless, titles should be descriptive of the idea.
Only make text posts; all images must be embedded or linked in a text post.
Don’t be vague; suggest a specific improvement or feature.
Format your posts well; don’t post walls of text.
When making a discussion post, you need to contribute to the discussion yourself.

Image posts will be automatically removed. Unformatted or vague posts are at risk of removal.

7 | Don't suggest planned or existing features (including parity).

Don’t post suggestions for parity between Bedrock and Java; this is already planned as a long-term goal.
Consult the Minecraft Wiki to ensure that what you’re suggesting isn’t already in or planned for the game.
Suggesting ideas for the execution of planned features is still allowed.

Parity suggestions or suggestions for existing features will be removed.

8 | Don't suggest scrapped or unused features without significant reworks.

Don’t suggest to reimplement removed, scrapped, or unused features, such as illusioners and red dragons, without a substantial rework. They're unused in their current state for a reason.
Don’t suggest to remove features or revert them to a previous state without sufficient reasoning. Saying, "Remove phantoms because I don't like them," doesn't make for constructive discussion.

Posts suggesting the unmodified reimplementation or unjustified removal of a feature are at risk of removal.

9 | Don't suggest jokes, easter eggs, or overly unrealistic ideas.

Don’t suggest ideas far removed from Minecraft’s theming, such as space content, firearms, modern vehicles, etc.
Don’t suggest jokes or easter eggs, even for April Fools’.
Don’t suggest extremely unbalanced ideas, such as getting diamonds from dirt or a stack of netherite blocks from a single structure.

Posts deemed unrealistic are at risk of removal.