Covid Slashed Consumer Choices. This Is Why They Aren’t Coming Back.

maynarkh, 4 months ago

Consumer choice in my vocabulary means that I can buy the same thing from different companies, so I, and other consumers, have the ability to “vote with our wallet”. I don’t care how many different colours you offer your thing, I care whether you are abusing a monopolistic market and if you hike prices I am able to buy from people who don’t.

Consumer choice was dead before the pandemic, and it wasn’t COVID that killed it, but unchecked mergers and acquisitions, and the US’ refusal to enforce basic antitrust law, twisting and breaking global markets.

SCB, 4 months ago

This is not what “consumer choice” means in this article, and per the article, the consolidation of retail choice at major retailers carves a spot for smaller businesses to offer the variety you’re looking for.

In a sense, this is a damper on the thing you don’t want - it’s a slight nullification of the “Wal-Mart effect”

the_post_of_tom_joad, 4 months ago

Consumer choice in my vocabulary means that I can buy the same thing from different companies

Right, and recognizing as you do that articles like these are part of the grift, not a separate, objectvely written report by an entity helping us understand the world, is an important lesson for today’s citizen. One very few of us know. This article wants to reframe consumer choice as flavors and colors from a monopoly, not your correct definition.

Anyone interested in how that works in this article specifically that cannot see it is welcome to pm me, i love breaking down shit like this to the point i annoy people so beware tho

ChunkMcHorkle, 4 months ago (edited 1 month ago)

deleted by creator

avidamoeba, 4 months ago

I think that voting with your wallet is yet another part of the delusion. It’s portrayed by traditional economic theory as fairly universally applicable with some exceptions. I think the reality is showing it might be the other way around. That it works in a limited set of cases and it doesn’t in most. If you think about it, if voting with your wallet works for a set of goods, then that has to be a competitive market. Then voting with your wallet should be able to produce winners and losers. What often happens to the losers is them or their productive assets getting scooped up by the winners. In either case that makes the market less competitive. Rinse and repeat until you end up with a single or a couple of choices for that good. E.g. you end up with a couple of grocers.

maynarkh, 4 months ago

My “finished econ 101 on the second try with mediocre grades” knowledge says that new companies should get created to compete against the winners if they start abusing the paradigm. In reality, I of course see companies raising the barrier to entry through vertical integration and regulatory capture, among other things.

SCB, 4 months ago

In reality, I of course see companies raising the barrier to entry through vertical integration and regulatory capture, among other things.

This article is about this happening less because it isn’t profitable.

avidamoeba, 4 months ago

Exactly. Market failure is described in econ 101 but as I remember it, it’s not emphasized as the typical case but rather as the exception. In reality it seems like it’s the other way around. Which … makes sense … given that competition is not efficient for maximizing profit among other variables.

numberfour002, 4 months ago

Covid slashed a lot of things on the consumer side.

I was just contemplating today about how many things I’ve purchased, just in the last few months, that have been defective. A pair of shoes, thermostats, blankets, and more. Since December I’ve had 2 somewhat expensive items where they would send me a replacement because the first item I received was defective, and it turns out the replacement has had the same issue. That’s never happened to me before, granted, this is obviously anecdotal.

And at the same time, it seems like they also slashed customer service not that most companies ever excelled at that to begin with. But even places like Amazon, which supposedly had top tier service, have fallen off significantly in that department.

So, here I am, yelling at the clouds, but I do wonder where it all ends.

spudwart, 4 months ago

“Capitalism drives innovation”

MisterNeon, 4 months ago

I was unemployed before and through most of COVID. I have lost a great deal of fondness for material things. I don’t have a lot of opportunities to impress my peers so, “keeping up with the Joneses” is not a high priority.

I can’t be the only member of the millennial generation that sees the pursuit of wealth as sisyphean.

shredderdoitbetta, 4 months ago

The response to COVID was the largest upward transfer of wealth in history. Monopolies? No corporate kings.

Jezebelley3D, 4 months ago

Yep and they're still making record profits in the gift of "inflation" when it's just permanent price gouging now that they have a publicly accepted excuse. How is it inflation when they're making substantially more revenue year over year?