Banned from r/news for deleting a 10 year old comment with redact. Guess the mods there have no backbone. No big deal to me since I'm deleting my account soon but be aware.
Just got back a message from the mods who told me to grow up and called me a 'hero'. They also muted me for 28 days so I can't message them any more. My reply to their ban was this "Banned for deleting my own comment in a 10 year old thread? Funny."
You can consider your Reddit account permabanned too. Powermods will typically report any "backtalk" to the Reddit admins which basically will get you permabanned no matter your infraction history.l
That's fine with me I was deleting it on the 30th anyhow. Plus this should highlight the pathetic atmosphere over there for anyone who is on the fence about leaving.
Yep will hold off on deleting the account until I’m sure they are finished reverting our content updates/edits. Just finished editing over 11 years of comments/posts with redact.dev
I have deleted all my comment's spez had made the platform impossible for me to return to with his coward behaviour. "Answered" 14 questions, then stopped answering and ran off to the press, he's a coward.
Who knew that the powermods Spez spefifically appointed to the main subreddits would be power throating his boot so much they're shitting out his bootlaces?
Fun fact: Being banned from a community, or reddit as a whole, does not remove content that wasnt specifically removed by mods... it also doesn't restrict you from editing and removing existing comments.
That's silly, any Reddit moderators that actually care about deleted/edited comments can easily configure automoderator to remove the comment. There's no need to go on a frenzy to ban every single person editing/removing old comments.
And trust me there are a lot of people editing/deleting comments right now.
And trust me there are a lot of people editing/deleting comments right now.
I did even edit and remove old comments via Redact with keywords and more before that fiasco they all just got now super sensitive because their power tripping janitor position is in danger.
I was abruptly permanently banned from a sub I have posted in for years for “ban evasion.” I wasn’t banned in any account I use in that sub. I had been inadvertently banned over 6 months ago when a mod accidentally clicked my name but was unbanned hours later when I noticed and told them.
Supposedly Reddit tagged my to the mods of the sub for ban evasion. When told the mods, they sent a ticket to admins who abruptly permanently banned me from Reddit. I appealed, showing them the messages from the mods where they apologized for banning me, and it went no where.
I really think the admins are clamping down wherever they see dissent. I imagine it has more to do with participating in spez’s AMA than anything. Anything to get rid of users that are against their changes.
Technically it's the "edit" they ban for, not the "delete".
The Reddit history deletion tools like to edit every comment before deleting them.
This was (is?) a privacy "best practice" based on the understanding that Reddit, Inc. can recover the text of deleted comments, but not the edit history. Just what the comment said at the time of deletion.
We will still have access to a deleted comment. So, yes, if you'd like to ensure that something is completely removed, editing would accomplish that.
Edit: to clarify, the delete button does delete the content from public view on the site. The differentiator with the edit button is that we simply don't store old edits. People can choose to take advantage of this by editing away the text.
In the case of deleting your comments to protest Reddit's decision, I'm not sure editing is really helpful. It's technically possible but very unlikely IMO that they would do something like a mass undelete just to keep your content on their site.
Yea, nothing prevents them from fetching the pre-edited content from their daily or weekly database backups. Media such as images and video might be harder to restore, but "soft" deletes on that type of storage are common, and editing a comment to remove an embed won't delete the embed source.
Yes, it's obviously technically possible to recover from a backup whether or not you edit. If anything, alienth was probably sharing that they can see deleted comments with no extra work required at all.
My point was that "editing before deleting" is done by these shredding tools because of the comment I quoted. It does nothing to prevent third parties from keeping their own copy, and is at worst an inconvenience to Reddit, Inc.
Therefore I'm not sure there's any real value to it for this kind of use.
Yeah it would probably be illegal to use the data for anything in the event of a GDPR removal.
They do technically still have it in their backups, most likely. It should be covered in Reddit's ToS.
According to France’s GDPR supervisory authority, CNIL, organisations don’t have to delete backups when complying with the right to erasure.
Nonetheless, they must clearly explain to the data subject that backups will be kept for a specified length of time (outlined in your retention policy).
If you decide to go down this route, you should bear in mind that other supervisory authorities might be stricter and that you must be able to demonstrate that it’s impractical to delete backup data.
Many of the main subs of reddit are super cranky with the mods. did post once a Original video on R/funny and it got removed was Threatened with a ban because i needed to proof its mine.
i asked then how and they said "usually you have Multiple recordings from different angles to proof" ... ye everyone got 5 camera people recording at all times lol
Meanwhile on the mainpage of R/funny was Simpsons , futurama , and more series clips wonder how they proofed with multiple angles that they own Simpsons lol
Admins and mods will likely be more vigilant about deleted posts and comments at least until things settle, so it might be better to abandon now, then delete later.
That is what I was thinking earlier today when I edited 13 years worth of comments and deleted all of my posts. I figure they will make it impossible unless you are protected by GDPR or something similar.
I recommend waiting to delete anyway, because you won't be able to delete any comments/posts on subs that are private. Hopefully deletion scripts will still work after the API change 😬
With the threat of removing mods for participating in the blackout, I wonder if some of them are deliberately just being extra ban-happy as an alternative.
Sub status don't mean squat if the users don't want to post.
I thought I replied already to this so this might be a double.. I think they are just a bootlicker who needs to go outside more often. Based on the reply I got from them I don't think they give a shit about their users just their power.
Add comment