Twitter Sued for $250 Million by Music Publishers asserting Copyright Infringement

https://i.imgur.com/kjV97t4.png

Twitter Hit With $250 Million Copyright-Infringement Lawsuit From Music Publishers

https://variety.com/2023/music/news/twitter-250-million-copyright-infringement-lawsuit-music-publishers-1235644414/


The National Music Publishers Assn., acting on behalf of 17 major music publishers, is filing a federal copyright infringement lawsuit against Twitter for its failure to license and pay for the music widely available on its platform.

The complaint seeks more than $250 million in damages for hundreds of thousands of noticed infringements of approximately 1,700 works.

“Twitter fuels its business with countless infringing copies of musical compositions, violating Publishers’ and others’ exclusive rights under copyright law,” the complaint reads in part. “While numerous Twitter competitors recognize the need for proper licenses and agreements for the use of musical compositions on their platforms, Twitter does not, and instead breeds massive copyright infringement that harms music creators…

“Twitter knows perfectly well that neither it nor users of the Twitter platform have secured licenses for the rampant use of music being made on its platform as complained of herein,” it continues. “Nonetheless, in connection with its highly interactive platform, Twitter consistently and knowingly hosts and streams infringing copies of musical compositions, including ones uploaded by or streamed to Tennessee residents and including specific infringing material that Twitter knows is infringing. Twitter also routinely continues to provide specific known repeat infringers with use of the Twitter platform, which they use for more infringement. Twitter profits handsomely from its infringement of Publishers’ repertoires of musical compositions. …

“Twitter’s unlawful conduct has caused and continues to cause substantial and irreparable harm to Publishers, their songwriter clients, and the entire music ecosystem. Twitter’s unlawful conduct enriches Twitter at Publishers’ and their songwriters’ expense and to the detriment of their copyrighted musical compositions. Twitter has rebuffed calls for it to obtain the licenses or other agreements needed for musical compositions to be lawfully used on its platform.”

An email to Twitter’s press account requesting comment returned an autoreply with a poop emoji.

The plaintiffs include: Concord, UMPG, peermusic, ABKCO Music, Anthem Entertainment, Big Machine Music, BMG Rights Management, Hipgnosis Songs Group, Kobalt Music Publishing America, Mayimba Music, Reservoir Media Management, Sony Music Publishing, Spirit Music Group, The Royalty Network, Ultra Music Publishing, Warner Chappell Music, and Wixen Music Publishing.

The NMPA has aggressively filed or threatened similar legal action against companies in the past, including TikTok, Twitch, Peloton, Roblox and others, which usually result in an agreement or settlement in the publishers’ favor. Twitter has undergone multiple layoffs and policy changes since it was acquired by Elon Musk last year.

NMPA President & CEO David Israelite said, “Twitter stands alone as the largest social media platform that has completely refused to license the millions of songs on its service. Twitter knows full well that music is leaked, launched, and streamed by billions of people every day on its platform. No longer can it hide behind the DMCA and refuse to pay songwriters and music publishers.”

iamlyth,

How do DMCA takedown requests work on federated social media? Do instance runners bear responsibility of complying to requests?

philluminati,

Yeah I'm guessing as the need for moderation of content grows as user activity on a server grows, server operators have the same growing responcibility for DMCA takedowns as well.

TheCookieButter,

Does make for some concern. Unlike Musk/Twitter most federated instance wouldn't be able to fund a legal dispute or ignore warnings.

Upside being some instances will be hosted in more legally indifferent countries and the game of whack-a-mole as more instances pop up. It'll be closer to their attempts fighting piracy sites than other social media, I imagine.

QHC,
QHC avatar

An email to Twitter’s press account requesting comment returned an autoreply with a poop emoji.

While hilarious, this simple statement in a legal filing does so much to underscore how insecure, weak and petty Musk (and probably all billionaires) really are.

Probably doesn't help their legal case at all, either!

ThreeHalflings,

I think that's the reporter talking, not the lawyer.

MrsEaves,
MrsEaves avatar

Yeah, I’m really tired of reading this line in every news article about Twitter I read. They should have quietly disabled that auto reply months ago so the line would become “Twitter did not respond for comment” like every other company with bad press. That’s going to look terrible to a judge.

Khalic,

What happens if a judge send them an email and gets a poop emoji as answer? It’s kind of fascinating

ThreeHalflings,

A judge is pretty unlikely to send an email to the public pr address of a company about an ongoing matter.

DubiousInterests,

I cannot believe this guy still has not rehired his press team and is still just using a poop emoji for all press emails.

acid,

nice

gkd,

Big yikes!

HappyMeatbag,
@HappyMeatbag@beehaw.org avatar

I can’t decide who to root for here. They both suck, so I guess I’ll just enjoy the fact that they’re fighting and I don’t have to care at all.

Blackfeathr, (edited )

To me this is like watching a rat and a cockroach fight. You hate em both, and you want neither to win, but you just hope that the winner will be hurt really badly.

briellebouquet,
briellebouquet avatar

cool so elon musk, one of the worst people in the world, going up against the organizations responsible for twitch streamers having to mute audio when licensed songs play in video games they're streaming.

so like 2 of the worst organizations in the world. i hope they both lose.

pbjamm,
@pbjamm@beehaw.org avatar

May the Earth open up and swallow them both whole.

sorenant,

Alien vs Predator

DubiousInterests,

Don't worry. No matter who wins, we still lose.

hemko,

I do want twitter to get hurt, but not like this if it can cascade down to smaller social media like Lemmy and Mastodon.

All laws restricting user generated content in internet will hurt users and small platforms the most. Big platforms can afford to deal with it, but the cost is paid by users and content creators again

Sharpiemarker,

Boy this isn't their year. Shocking with someone so brilliant at the helm. /s in case that was too subtle.

KeatonPotatoes,

Good

nevernevermore,
nevernevermore avatar

I have no idea how Musk has managed to keep Twitter operational for so long, is he actually a genius? The answer is no. No he isn't.

flybynightpotato,

Shows how powerful inertia can be. Momentum keeps things shambling along even as critical parts fly off.

smolgumball,
@smolgumball@lemmy.world avatar

Does this basically come down to "Twitter doesn't want to spend the compute to fingerprint media uploads?"

I know that's been a massive cost sink for YouTube with their Content ID technology, and I don't imagine Elbow is in a hurry to burn even more money at the moment.

PorkrollPosadist,

let them fight

gormster,

They can only do this is Twitter is ignoring DMCA takedown requests… that’s the whole point of the DMCA. I know Twitter is understaffed but surely they haven’t gotten rid of this system?

Trebach,

Maybe that was replaced with the poop emoji auto-reply as well.

squirmin,

Well they aren't paying rent in SF or Colorado, they aren't paying Google for hosting. It sounds like they are basically trying to get sued by everyone all at once.

4am,
@4am@lemmy.world avatar

Elon tanking “the public square” on purpose = no more criticism of the oligarch takeover of America.

How will we know what they’re doing if they control the media, the internet, etc

Why do you think the Saudis got in on the deal? They wanted Elon to tank it because the Middle East is afraid of another Arab Spring.

This is what capital does when it feels threatened. It’s not a dog that can be trained, it’s a wild animal that will hunt and kill. Quite literally if necessary.

We should never have let anyone on this planet acquire enough wealth to rival smaller nation states. They’re unelected kings, and they sure as shit fancy themselves that way.

darrsil,

The system probably requires some sort of user intervention, and those people were all fired

MedicPigBabySaver,

Ha, fuck Elon.

So damn glad i changed my mind about buying a Tesla 3 series when they were first taking down payment for orders.

I hadn't realized what a kooky POS that is the Musk.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • technology@beehaw.org
  • tacticalgear
  • DreamBathrooms
  • InstantRegret
  • magazineikmin
  • khanakhh
  • Youngstown
  • ngwrru68w68
  • slotface
  • everett
  • rosin
  • thenastyranch
  • kavyap
  • GTA5RPClips
  • cisconetworking
  • JUstTest
  • normalnudes
  • osvaldo12
  • ethstaker
  • mdbf
  • modclub
  • Durango
  • tester
  • provamag3
  • cubers
  • Leos
  • anitta
  • megavids
  • lostlight
  • All magazines