cendawanita

cendawanita, 9 months ago

A look at how Beijing influences Chinese media, diaspora in Malaysia and The Hong Kong infowar in Malaysia

cendawanita, 9 months ago

@whatshisays it's really interesting how this is seen as subversive behaviour, basically, but not enough for an outright ban

cendawanita, 9 months ago (edited 9 months ago)

@chemical_cutthroat

If I do a book report based on a book that I picked up from the library, am I violating copyright? If I write a movie review for a newspaper that tells the plot of the film, am I violating copyright?

The first conceptual mistake in this analogy is assuming the LLM entity is "writing". A person or a sentient being writing is still showing signs of intellectual work, which is how the example book report and movie review will not be accused of plagiarism, which is very very basically stealing someone's output but one that is not made legally ownership of (which then brings it to copyright infringement territory).

LLMs are producing text based on statistical probability meaning it is quite literally aping/replicating the aesthetic form of a known genre of textual output, which in these cases are given the legal status of intellectual property. So yes, an LLM-generated textual output that is in the form of a book report or movie review looks the way it does by copying with no creative intent previous works of the genre. It's the same way YouTube video essays get taken down if it's just a collection of movie clips that might sound like a full dialogue. Of course in that example yt clip, if you can argue it's a creative output where an artist is forming a new piece out of a collage of previous media, the rights owner to those movie clips might lose their claim to the said video. You can't make that defence with OpenAI.

@stopthatgirl7

cendawanita, 9 months ago

@chemical_cutthroat
Again, all of your analogical effort presumes that an LLM is synthesizing. When I say, specifically, they generate outputs based on statistical probability it's not at all the same as a sentient process of reiterative learning based on their available knowledge.

If you can't get that distinction, then all the effort to respond to you will expect too much from me (personally; I wish the best to others who'd like). If you're really sincere though, honestly it's been best elaborated by Timnit Gebru and Emily Bender in their writings about the "stochastic parrot". Please do have a read. https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3442188.3445922
@stopthatgirl7

cendawanita, 10 months ago

The deliberate amnesia combined with japanese post-ww2 charm offensive that includes a lot of foreign investment and overseas aid in the region really contributed to many Southeast Asians having no great memory of the war and its consequences. (I know people of Malaysian Chinese background who'd unironically visited the Yasukuni shrine, for example)

cendawanita, 10 months ago

Just adding the post I made on updated tags being tracked on fedi: https://kbin.social/m/magASEAN/p/739715