Does ANYONE like autoplaying videos on news sites / articles?

In today’s fast-paced digital world, we often rely on various online platforms to quench our thirst for knowledge, information, and entertainment. Among these platforms, news websites hold a significant position as they allow us to stay updated about current events across the globe. However, despite their essential role in delivering crucial content, many of these sites have resorted to irritating tactics that negatively impact user experience. One such tactic is the automatic playback of videos accompanied by full audio when one opens their webpage.

This practice has become increasingly common among news sites due to the belief that users prefer a multimedia experience over plain text articles. However, there is no empirical evidence to support this assumption. On the contrary, many have raised concerns over these autoplaying videos. These concerns range from audio intrusion into private spaces, lack of control over sound output, to the consumption of data and battery life on mobile devices. The most prominent criticism against this practice stems from the mismatch between the video’s subject matter and the article itself. In other words, these videos are unrelated to the content of the page and often serve solely as advertisements, disruptive interfaces, or attempts at misleading engagement metrics.

Does ANYONE actually like these videos? I typically scramble to find the close and/or mute button as soon as I can. Infuriating.

FluffyPotato,

I have heard others complain about it but as long as I have used Firefox videos haven’t autoplayed on anything so I would hate if they did that but currently I’m good

MadMadBunny,

I loathe it deeply.

UmeU,

Google news is my go to… I’m sure someone can tell me why that’s bad and that I’m stupid ):

I am in the habit of right click, open in new tab… then as that tab is loading, right click the tab and ‘mute tab’.

I’m using Firefox but I’m sure the other browsers have a mute tab function.

I seriously just want to read articles. I don’t want some loud bullshit screaming at me every time I open an article.

DelightfullyDivisive,

Interesting. I use Google News as well, and I have never had audio play. I tend to use it on mobile, and my default browser on mobile is Firefox. Specifically Firefox in private browser mode, so I don’t have to worry about cookies.

I use Firefox on the desktop as well, but not usually in private mode. I also don’t ever have video autoplay that way. I’m not sure why. I don’t think I installed any extensions to turn it off, but I might have tweaked the browser settings shortly after installing.

UmeU,

I meant when I click on any of the articles curated by Google news… a lot of the sites that Google news aggregates are sites that auto play videos.

DelightfullyDivisive,

I think that we’re talking about the same thing. When I read those articles curated by Google news in my mobile browser, I have never, not once, had audio play. Maybe try Firefox mobile?

UmeU,

I’m talking about on desktop, although come to think of it, I think on mobile in Firefox focus, the videos auto play on mute… maybe because my phone is on mute, not sure. I am using Firefox for both now. Ditched chrome about a year ago when I noticed edge was actually working better for things, then ditched edge during the YouTube debacle a few months back. Super happy with Firefox + UBlock.

Also maybe my local news sites are shittier than your local news sites. It’s mostly the local news sites that have the shitty auto play, along with some shitty national sites like Fox News. And even though I do avoid fox like the plague, sometimes I like to see how a legitimate story gets spun by the right.

With that said, others have mentioned that on desktop using Firefox, and probably mobile as well, rather than selecting mute tab super quick, there are settings to prevent auto play all together.

Trucchucchut,

Why are you using chatgpt for that content? Don’t bring that sh* to lemmy please

Kolanaki,
@Kolanaki@yiffit.net avatar

Hell no. I thought we established this shit pretty early on with the web when it was just auto playing audio.

felsiq,

I don’t normally comment on anything but I literally have to know: did you use ChatGPT to write the first two paragraphs of your post? I skimmed your last couple posts and I don’t think you’re a bot, but this one and what looks like a battle rap(?) from the perspective of trump just give me major ChatGPT vibes. No judgement either way, I’m just curious if ChatGPT’s out here passing the Turing test lol.

DinosaurSr,

Haha my brain just automatically skipped those first 2 paragraphs. I had to go back and read them, but they definitely sound like gpt

Longpork3,

Well shit, me too. Have we inadvertently trained our brains to ignore walls of garbage text?

sgibson5150,

I especially hate the auto-play in feed thing in the Android YouTube app. Threre’s no audio but it makes me feel jumpy and irritable bc I’m not in control. The iOS version has an option to turn it off, which must be an Apple requirement. It makes no sense not to offer the option to YouTube subscribers since we don’t see ads. Google is just wasting their bandwidth. Workaround is to start a video and pause it, but that’s stupid. Just let me turn the shit off.

pete_the_cat,

You can definitely turn that off, or at least I can on my S23. It may be a YouTube Premium feature.

sgibson5150,

Ok. Show me a screen shot. In the iOS version, the option is called “Playback in feeds” and appears at the bottom of the General section in Settings. This option does not exist in the Android version that I have. As I stated, I am a YouTube subscriber.

imgur.com/a/YQgtzPV

pete_the_cat,

Settings -> General -> Playback in feeds. Options are Always on, WiFi Only, and off

v19. 09.38 downloaded from The Play Store

sgibson5150,

I could kiss you. I’m very sorry that I doubted you, Mr. Cat. I don’t know when they added this but I guess I never saw it bc I expected the options to be in the same order in the iOS version.

pete_the_cat,

Haha no problem!

z00s,

Ugh the only worse thing than that is the popups that beg for your email address the microsecond your mouse leaves the page area.

Whoever figures out how to block that shit would become king of all england

pete_the_cat,

Or as soon as you scroll down there’s a full page pop-up asking you to sign up or some other bullshit.

Pyroglyph,
@Pyroglyph@lemmy.world avatar

I hate them too.

I come to news sites to read articles, not watch videos. If I wanted to watch videos I would go to YouTube. It’s as simple as that.
Making them autoplay is just adding insult to injury (as well as wasting bandwidth for literally no reason).

Let’s do some napkin maths while we think how much energy has been wasted by autoplaying a video for every visitor.
If I were to guess, the video player pre-caches a few seconds of content, maybe up to 10. That’s a fair few MB worth of reasonable quality video/audio data. Now multiply that for every single visitor. That’s a lot of wasted energy. The page itself is likely ~1MB in size (at least you’d hope), so they’re potentially increasing their costs by an order of magnitude by having the videos autoplay.

It’s monumentally stupid.

Num10ck,
FinishingDutch,
@FinishingDutch@lemmy.world avatar

Any site that does it will not get a second visit from me. It’s really, REALLY fucking annoying when they do it. Especially for people who keep their volume up in general.

SuperSpruce,

It was precisely this crap that got me to switch from AdBlock Plus or other “fair” adblockers that let some unintrusive ads through to support the website, to uBlock origin, because it can remove those stupid auto playing videos.

I didn’t like the scorched earth approach of uBO then (and still sometimes now), but any text and/or image based website shoving autoplaying videos down my throat doesn’t deserve any support.

P.S. I’d like an optional way to allow unintrusive ads through in uBlock origin per site while still blocking any trackers that are not useless if the ad didn’t exist.

spittingimage,
@spittingimage@lemmy.world avatar

I appreciate it in the same way I’d enjoy having an entire cactus jammed up my ass.

Which is to say, no.

Sotuanduso,

Not here, that’s for sure, but keep in mind the community you’re asking.

RobotToaster,
@RobotToaster@mander.xyz avatar

Their advertisers do

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • asklemmy@lemmy.world
  • tacticalgear
  • DreamBathrooms
  • InstantRegret
  • magazineikmin
  • osvaldo12
  • Youngstown
  • ngwrru68w68
  • slotface
  • everett
  • rosin
  • thenastyranch
  • kavyap
  • GTA5RPClips
  • modclub
  • JUstTest
  • normalnudes
  • cubers
  • ethstaker
  • mdbf
  • Durango
  • khanakhh
  • tester
  • provamag3
  • cisconetworking
  • Leos
  • anitta
  • megavids
  • lostlight
  • All magazines