Amadeo's Pixel Fold dead after 4 days of light use

https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/b0c5a6b4-eb21-4bbd-be88-21c4fb0e4c2b.jpeg

"I didn't do anything to deserve this. The phone sat on my desk while I wrote about it, and I would occasionally stop to poke the screen, take a screenshot, or open and close it. It was never dropped or exposed to a significant amount of grit, nor had it gone through the years of normal wear and tear that phones are expected to survive. This was the lightest possible usage of a phone, and it still broke."

This can happen to any phone of course — there are numerous threads on reddit of faulty S23 phones that are only days old, and of course the first Galaxy fold phones were problematic — but still. Rough start!

applejacks,
@applejacks@lemmy.world avatar

average first gen google product

SpaceNoodle,

Pretty sad when the Fire Phone outlives you

WrenofDelpan,

Shame. I have a Samsung Z Flip 4, and I'm blown away by how much I love this phone. I'm desperately hoping foldable phones are the future, or an expected option like how "pro" or bigger size models are. The only way I can see that being the reality is widespread adoption by manufacturers, and if new models run into issues like this that hurts their future.

Dark_Blade,
@Dark_Blade@lemmy.world avatar

tbh I think foldables are a bit too clunky to be the future. Rollable displays though…fuck yeah sign me up!

Holyginz,

I have the 3 and while I had it replaced once because of something similar happening as mentioned, it has been a wonderful phone. I thought about getting the 4 but couldn't justify the cost of replacing since it's already such an expensive phone lol.

BenignLarency,

Idk respectfully, devices used for spans of time counting in days is far from "dead". You got a leamon, it happens.

Talk to me when we see devices dying after a handful of months/ within the first year (when you can't just immediately get your money back because you put in a return).

FoxBJK,
@FoxBJK@midwest.social avatar

The article goes into great detail to try and explain what happened and why this is very likely a design flaw.

Labotomized,

Yeah....and how much was that phone? Like $2k USD. That's not okay in the slightest. It's okay to get a lemon item from amazon because we all know its cheap crap, but for a $2k phone!!? Hell no. How about google or whoever is manufacturing this thing do some proper QC and R&D and not sell shitty two thousand dollar phones??

Silvus,

lemons happen, price and device dont matter. if you male millions of a product a 1% failure rate will still be a fuckton of devices.

Dark_Blade,
@Dark_Blade@lemmy.world avatar

Lemons do happen, even when a device costs as much as this one. What remains to be seen is if this turns out to be a widespread issue.

dantheclamman,
@dantheclamman@lemmy.world avatar

This wasn't a lemon. There was a specific flaw in the design that left the oled exposed to debris and it tore

Bucket_of_Truth,

I just got a Pixel 7, had the Fold in my cart originally but thankfully did a little bit of research into foldy phones. One reviewer said to be careful if you go out to a beach or anywhere with sand because it can get into it and damage the inside screen. I go to the beach all the time.

The seam over the hinge looks hideous in regular use too. Too noticable of a bump. I don't trust the hinge to stay 100% tight forever either. It reminds me of the first Moto Droid, the keyboard lock often wouldn't lock so it would just slide freely.

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

I'm surprised people still want foldable phones. IMO they're a gimmick - worse, a gimmick based on technology that clearly isn't "all the way there" yet.

Dark_Blade,
@Dark_Blade@lemmy.world avatar

Eh, the tech is undeniably cool. Problem is though, as you said, the tech is nowhere near where it needs to be.

Tired8281,

I want one that's already 'there'. I appreciate the work and sacrifice early adopters are doing to help me get there.

CoderKat,
CoderKat avatar

Same. I make good money and can easily enough deal with the expense. But the durability is something they need to improve to get me on board.

I think it'd be pretty neat for the extra screen real estate, improve "front facing" camera, and for watching videos. It's mostly small things, but they are cool!

iamsgod,

why not? having a phone and tablet in one device is a godsend. if the technology is mature, that is

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

I've never really liked tablets - I much prefer a real computer. That probably explains our disconnect.

iamsgod,

tbf, it's not like I use tablet as a computer replacement, only for media consumption. having an extra screen real estate when you need it is convenient

stephenc,

My single tablet use case is ebooks. I despise the ugly "e-ink" readers and love the simplicity of a cheap tablet. It's really the only way to read in any situation because reading from even a small laptop is inconvenient in the places I read in.

Of course, my smartphone use case isn't that big -- emergency calls/texts, typing out grocery lists, and portable storage. I have a simple talk/text plan, no mobile data. Never understood the need for one. In an absolute need, I can seek out somewhere with wifi and use that, but I don't really even do that. Just never been a smartphone guy. Wish payphones and pagers were still around so I could ditch mobile phones completely.

Computers are still so far ahead of any mobile device in usability and convenience that it's not worth using mobile devices casually.

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

My single tablet use case is ebooks. I despise the ugly “e-ink” readers and love the simplicity of a cheap tablet.

Dang, you've got eyes of steel. I could never read books on an LED screen - the eyestrain is just too much. E-ink doesn't have that issue.

stephenc,

I don't get that, really. I get eyestrain from e-ink. It's just so hard to read because of the way it looks. Reading on a tablet is just like anything else. Also, you should know that using a tablet isn't like reading a piece of paper -- it emits light, rather than absorbing it. Dark mode is your friend. I think that's people's problems trying to read on a tablet, they don't use dark mode and end up staring into a bright light for hours on end.

Dark mode should be the natural, default state on all computers, tablets, smartphones, etc. You're goinjg to ruin your eyes staring into a white screen.

AsimovsRobot,

Do books make your eyes strain as well? I see no difference between a printed book and a high ppi e-ink display. I can read for hours on one and be strained af after 30 minutes reading on an oled display. Weird!

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

I do already use dark mode (Dark Reader ftw) but for me, any emissive display seems to cause eyestrain over a long enough period. I rarely use the backlight on my e-ink reader, so it reads like crisp print on paper.

Maybe you were using really low-res/first gen e-ink? Or perhaps we're just built different :p

stephenc,

Nah, I think we're just built differently. Well, I'm built differently, with spare, broken, defective parts. Such is my life. Even modern e-ink readers give me eyestrain.

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

Honestly, I'm jealous. Being a programmer means I spend a lot of time staring at LED displays whether I like it or not 🙃

dantheclamman,
@dantheclamman@lemmy.world avatar

I'd really like one. The idea of a pocketable tablet sounds appealing. But the durability and expense issues leave me unwilling to take the risk

Bucket_of_Truth,

I saw someone who had a Nintendo DS emulator loaded up and it looked sooooo cool.

CoderKat,
CoderKat avatar

That's a great usage! It'd be cool if there were apps and games that were designed for the two screens like DS games were, but it's probably too niche of a market for most apps to target. Though perhaps someday it'll be more common.

rDrDr,

I did that on mine with the full skinning to make it look like an actual DS. Can confirm, it's pretty cool.

solivine,

Woah that sounds so cool! Can you share?

solivine,

Woah that's so cool! Can you share?

rDrDr,

https://www.androidcentral.com/how-turn-your-galaxy-z-fold-3-nintendo-ds

UESPA_Sputnik,
@UESPA_Sputnik@lemmy.world avatar

I thought there were gimmicks too but I now think that somewhere down the line – once they're more refined and less expensive – I'd like to get one.

I was tempted to buy the Pixel Tablet until I realized that I don't want a second device. I'd rather like a multi-purpose device. And the Pixel Fold seems to have a great form factor to use it as a "normal" phone, and then switch to the large screen when you want to do something that you'd normally do on a tablet, just with the benefit of having all your settings, apps and recent notifications right there with you. It's a seamless transition which is really neat.

CoderKat,
CoderKat avatar

I'm with you on the tablet thing. I even did buy a tablet many years ago, but barely used it. I think mostly because I didn't want to deal with carrying around another device.

Coablt,

I've been on the Galaxy Flip phones for a couple years now and I love them. I cannot see myself returning to a brick phone in the future. I think that as long as you treat the phone with a little respect, it will be fine. I'm not exactly gentle with mine and I have never had an issue.

BlackCoffee,

I had a Z Fold 2 for 2+ years before selling it and it was a great phone overall. Didn't feel like the technology "wasn't there yet" but it felt like a full fledged product and the built quality was really top notch.

What i agree with is that indeed the inner screen is a gimmick or the foldable idea itself. I found myself using the inner screen mostly for streaming and using the outer screen for literally anything else. Which meant that for 95% of the time I used the outer screen.

I think the Flip series has a way better usecase for a foldable because the fold Idea reduces the size of the "normal way of use" product.

I think the Fold expands on the "normal way of use" so it is easier put it in the gimmick territory.

I still think it is better to just get an Phone + Tablet overall if you want the best of both worlds.

But to be clear, this has been my experience as having had the Z fold 2 as a daily driver for 2+ years.

joedinkle,

Have you used one as a daily driver yet? They’re great!

I started with a SD2, then moved to the ZF4. I loved the Surface, but it’s design caused some issues that the ZF4 doesn’t have. The ZF4 is great, and really shows of Samsung’s software innovations to just the screen real estate.

Not sure I’d go back to a standard slate style phone.

keeb420,

the only reason im considering going back is the price. we already know the fold 5 is gonna be expensive, maybe samsung can drop the price some but not nearly enough for me right now. but im still happy with my fold 3. im not in a position to afford a $1500+ phone right now.

Killer,

The trick is trade in your old one so you're not paying full price for the new one.

solivine,

I definitely want one, my phone is currently a bit too small to watch things on, but a tablet is good for that. Reading too. I want the price to come down a bit first though.

Mr_Dr_Oink,

As a user of the galaxy fold 3 for almost 2 years i can say without a shadow of a doubt. Its not a gimmick. Ive genuinely had no issues with it in terms of durability or faults (i know there are some that did but i guess like many others i got lucky) I could never go back to a standard phone. Watching videos, browsing the web, playing games. Even stuff as simple as being able to see a whole picture without needing to zoom in to catch details, but still having the option to, has been brilliant.

Being able to use it closed for normal stuff and open for bigger stuff (honestly the majority of the time i have it open) is so functionally superior.

The camera options are great. I have a main set of cameras on the back, an under screen camera for the big inner screen and a front facing camera for the outer screen and if i want i can ipen the phone and use the main cameras as a selfie camera because the view finder can be displayed on the outer screen which when open is pointing towards me.

The multi tasking is pretty powerful too. I can have my budget open on sheets, my calculator open and my notepad open all together. I can have maps open along with my web browser for train times and my s pen notes app open for planning trips.

I guess it comes down to use case. If you dont use your phone the way i do then you might not get the same out of it as i do. But for those that do its a game changer.

But since you are fully entitled to yoyr opinion i wont expect you to change it because of mine. And i wont down vote your comment because im only here to offer the view point of someone who has used the phone for nearly 2 years (as i said before) as a different perspective.

Seriously i could never go back. Im sad that the pixel fold is not turning out to be as good as the galaxy because i was seriously considering making it my next phone. Guess ill be going for the next galaxy device.

Out of interest what about the tech is not all the way there yet? Im maybe not as clued in as you on that point as i felt like the fold 3 was the nail on the head for these types of devices.

colonial,
@colonial@lemmy.world avatar

Out of interest what about the tech is not all the way there yet?

The durability issue. I shouldn't have to rely on "getting lucky" if I want the display to not get a huge crease (or outright break, in the case of OP) - especially considering how expensive these devices are compared to standard phones.

d3Xt3r,

I've been using my Fold 4 since late last year, use it very heavily too, and haven't had any issues. I mean, sure, you could say that in theory it's not as durable as a regular phone, but that's just the nature of the tech - and you/the manufacturer will just have to cope up/come up with ways around it. Just like when all-glass phones were introduced and people critisiced manufacturers on that decision, and eventually glass phones started to use tougher materials like Gorilla Glass or Sapphire etc and became more resistant to falls and scratches. Of course, the most simplest solution was to employ a case. In any case, glass body phones are commonplace today and a glass body is considered a non-issue these days, for better or worse.

Don't forget that right now, price is the biggest barrier for foldables, so it's not like this is something that's being marketed to the layman - the audience is very niche, so they don't really need to make these as durable as regular phones to get high sales numbers, when the audience is so niche and the biggest barrier is the price.

Personally though, I'm not really worried about durability since Samsung have been very good with replacing any faulty foldables under warranty, and you could also opt for extended warranty if you intend to keep your device beyond the warranty period.

As an avid book/manga reader, web surfer and retro gamer, my Fold 4 has quickly turned from an impromptu indulgence to an indispensable device, and therefore to me, in no definition of the word, could it be considered "gimmicky".

Labotomized,

Yep that’s why you never buy the first generation of a new product!

MKBandit,

Let alone a first gen Google product

HidingCat,

Samsung'S first Fold didn't last long either, but the Fold 4 is a very usable phone!

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • android@lemmy.world
  • khanakhh
  • magazineikmin
  • osvaldo12
  • GTA5RPClips
  • mdbf
  • Youngstown
  • tacticalgear
  • slotface
  • rosin
  • kavyap
  • ethstaker
  • everett
  • thenastyranch
  • DreamBathrooms
  • megavids
  • InstantRegret
  • cubers
  • normalnudes
  • Leos
  • ngwrru68w68
  • cisconetworking
  • modclub
  • Durango
  • provamag3
  • anitta
  • tester
  • JUstTest
  • lostlight
  • All magazines
    •