Stripped of dignity, $22 left after rent — stories emerge as Ontario sued for halting basic income pilot

Tracey Crosson says she ate healthier, slept better and had more energy when she was receiving basic income payments from the Ontario government.

Now, she’s left with $22 every month after paying rent and relies on Meals on Wheels.

Crosson is just one of the thousands of people impacted after the province scrapped the basic income pilot project (OBI) nearly six years ago. The early cancellation of the program in 2018 is behind a class-action lawsuit that was certified by a Superior Court judge on March 4.

“When I was on the OBI, I got to go and get a steak for $10 and have that for dinner once a month,” said Crosson, who participated in the program in Thunder Bay and now lives in Toronto for better access to medical care. “Now, I don’t have the luxury for steak and hamburger and all that stuff.”

girlfreddy, (edited )
@girlfreddy@lemmy.ca avatar

DrugFraud, the scummiest skin bag ever, who Ontario has managed to elect twice as premier.

Maybe by next election Ontario will have learned its lesson.

whereisk,

I understand why journos do it, focusing on an individual’s plight. But this is just anecdote - give us some statistical data to support the story, then bring up the individual as representative example.

girlfreddy,
@girlfreddy@lemmy.ca avatar

There are some in the article …

Number of people using Ontario food banks rose nearly 40% last year: report

A single person on ODSP gets $1,308 a month for basic needs and shelter, or under $16,000 a year. A single person on OW receives $733 a month, amounting to less than $9,000 annually.

The Ontario Living Wage Network calculates the living wage in Thunder Bay at $19.80 an hour. For a person working 40 hours a week for 50 weeks a year, that would equate to an annual income of just below $40,000, not including tax deductions.

whereisk,

Yes, but nothing on what the article was focused on - the impact on individuals.

So we have no idea if it hit intended targets, if it improves lives better than other programs or differently etc. How it was used, did it enable people to escape a suffocating circumstances that then allowed them to thrive (a medical procedure, fleeing domestic abuse etc) or put more food on the table like the individual stories it had. Give us some statistical data.

girlfreddy,
@girlfreddy@lemmy.ca avatar

Because Druggie shut it down after a year (after promising to keep it)… well before any stats could be accumulated.

…wikipedia.org/…/Ontario_Basic_Income_Pilot_Proje…

whereisk,

That’s fucked, sorry, I had no idea.

ininewcrow,
@ininewcrow@lemmy.ca avatar

I don’t understand why conservatives can’t see this as an economic issue … sure you can play the socialism is bad card and paint a terrible picture of people living freely off the government but it doesn’t work like that.

No matter where you are on the political spectrum … the government will always pay for the poor.

Either …

  • be a conservative and take away all benefits for the poor and let them live on their own … and your government will end up paying for more policing, more security, more judicial services, more social services, more health care and more emergency services as people fall below a livable level and can’t take care of themselves any more … or they just fall into more crime and drug abuse as their lives degrade over time.
  • be a liberal socialist and give funds and supports directly to the poor and you’ll save money by reduced crime, reduced number of people drifting towards crime and reduced number of unhealthy people accessing your public and private health care that the government would have paid for any way.

It’s all the same money … either don’t pay and you’d end up paying for the consequences later … or pay it now and you’ll have less of a problem to pay for later.

And no … it won’t create a utopia where people will be holding hands in unity afterwards … there will still be problems, there will always be problems with any human system no matter how well meaning it is … it’s just that taking care of people makes the most economic sense. If you have a healthy nation full of functional people, they are all more likely to take part in the economy to make those wealthy capitalist leaders even more rich … by not helping people, all our energy is spent just trying to take care of people as minimally as possible and keep the system from falling apart.

Revan343,

Conservatives have a poor understanding of economics, as a rule.

fuckyou, (edited )

Because they know that they won’t directly benefit, that it will pose a threat to the old power structures they are in control of and know, because conservatives (and old people) by their nature are scared of progress and new things, because giving in to some level of equality would mean that they were wrong on any number of other things and that conservative ideology might not actually bring about the best possible society.

They see themselves as naturally privileged, and anything that may pose a threat to their power dominance will always be fought, just like in feudal times. It was never about money for them, the money was only a means to an end, to make sure social division and hierarchies were upheld and protected. If you start messing with the money, however, that would be the first birth pangs of a new revolution, and they know whose heads are going to roll.

Giving a fair share to everyone, even hypothetically, would be like admitting that the Emperor doesn’t wear shoes, and then socks, and then pants, and then all the other things and then all of a sudden we find them standing there all nekkid with their dick in their hands like a bunch of old fat white dudes jerking each other off in the middle of the town square.

E: Edited for poetry

alvvayson,

Conservatives have a deep need to feel superior to others.

The cruelty is the point.

If poor people have happy and fulfilling lives, then they can’t feel better than them.

Untitled4774,

A happy, healthy, educated population is a productive population.

Kichae, (edited )

No matter where you are on the political spectrum … the government will always pay for the poor.

They’re OK with the government paying for the poor, so long as the government is paying them for the poor.

Private prisons. HMOs and private hospitals. Company towns. Privatized services.

The problem with basic income is that it keeps the power to choose in the hands of the person. They’d be all too happy to have the government foot the bill directly for things, with the rider that they’re the one’s being paid.

The issue is always one of control. Money is just a medium for exercising that control. UBI puts control into the hands of the receiver – the poor, the unworthy.

n3m37h,

Can we hang Ford by the testicles too? Guy has fucked Ontario over every chance he got. And yet to get in trouble when he has been caught

fuckyou,

I’m up for some good old testicle hanging.

ThuleanPerspective2,

CHUCK DILATE HOT POCKETS FOR FREE SNEED CITY SLICKER FOR FREE I CAN’T SNEED’S SUCK COPE SNEED’S COPE JANNIES SNEED I CAN’T SNEED HOT POCKETS SEED SNEED CLEAN IT UP FLOYD HOT POCKETS FUCK CHUCK’S FLOYD SNEED SEETHE SEED JANNY CHUCK ON LEMMY ON LEMMY COPE CITY SLICKER HOT POCKETS CITY SLICKER FOR FREE CLEAN IT UP CLEAN IT UP CLEAN IT UP CHUCK’S FUCK CITY SLICKER CITY SLICKER FLOYD FLOYD FUCK FEED I CAN’T

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

COPE SEETHE SEED COPE COPE HOT POCKETS CHUCK CHUCK CHUCK’S SNEED’S AND SNEED DILATE CLEAN IT UP SEED ON LEMMY DILATE AND SNEED’S FLOYD SNEED’S FEED CHUCK HOT POCKETS CITY SLICKER FLOYD SEED AND ON LEMMY FLOYD I CAN’T FUCK SUCK SNEED’S DILATE FEED CHUCK’S AND AND I CAN’T SEETHE SNEED’S FLOYD COPE ON LEMMY SUCK DILATE I CAN’T FOR FREE FEED

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

COPE CITY SLICKER HOT POCKETS SEED CITY SLICKER SNEED ON LEMMY FEED FUCK ON LEMMY I CAN’T SNEED’S CLEAN IT UP CHUCK SUCK AND CITY SLICKER DILATE JANNIES CHUCK’S SNEED SEED CHUCK’S FUCK HOT POCKETS DILATE I CAN’T SEETHE COPE SNEED’S SUCK SEETHE FLOYD SNEED CHUCK’S SNEED CHUCK’S FLOYD SNEED’S CHUCK ON LEMMY CLEAN IT UP FEED FUCK SEED I CAN’T CHUCK’S AND HOT POCKETS HOT POCKETS

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

ON LEMMY CITY SLICKER CLEAN IT UP FOR FREE SNEED’S AND ON LEMMY JANNY FEED AND I CAN’T CLEAN IT UP FUCK SNEED’S DILATE FUCK I CAN’T CLEAN IT UP SNEED I CAN’T CHUCK FLOYD SEETHE I CAN’T JANNY FEED HOT POCKETS ON LEMMY DILATE CHUCK’S CLEAN IT UP SNEED’S FLOYD AND SNEED CHUCK FLOYD ON LEMMY CLEAN IT UP ON LEMMY SNEED’S CHUCK JANNY CHUCK SNEED FUCK JANNIES FUCK COPE FUCK

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

ON LEMMY DILATE SEETHE FUCK FUCK JANNIES SEED DILATE CLEAN IT UP HOT POCKETS SNEED’S JANNIES FLOYD AND AND SNEED FUCK AND FUCK JANNY SNEED’S HOT POCKETS SEED DILATE CITY SLICKER SEED JANNIES SNEED’S SUCK CHUCK’S JANNY AND JANNIES SEETHE DILATE SEETHE HOT POCKETS FEED FOR FREE SEED I CAN’T SEED SNEED’S I CAN’T HOT POCKETS SNEED ON LEMMY FUCK JANNY SNEED’S

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

CLEAN IT UP HOT POCKETS CLEAN IT UP SEETHE CHUCK JANNIES DILATE SNEED’S ON LEMMY SUCK AND JANNY JANNY FEED AND I CAN’T JANNIES SUCK CHUCK’S SEETHE HOT POCKETS FLOYD CHUCK’S SEED DILATE CHUCK CLEAN IT UP FEED DILATE FEED JANNY COPE CITY SLICKER CHUCK’S CHUCK SNEED SNEED’S FEED FUCK JANNY AND COPE SNEED JANNY ON LEMMY FLOYD ON LEMMY FOR FREE ON LEMMY CHUCK’S

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

SEED HOT POCKETS FLOYD CLEAN IT UP COPE COPE JANNIES CHUCK’S SNEED’S SEED JANNIES JANNY ON LEMMY AND CHUCK’S JANNIES DILATE SNEED’S CITY SLICKER JANNY SEED SNEED’S DILATE DILATE FEED CITY SLICKER DILATE JANNIES SNEED SEED SUCK AND CITY SLICKER SEETHE CLEAN IT UP SNEED COPE SNEED’S FEED I CAN’T DILATE SEETHE CHUCK’S CHUCK COPE SEETHE JANNIES SEETHE SEETHE AND

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

CITY SLICKER CHUCK’S DILATE JANNIES FEED CLEAN IT UP ON LEMMY ON LEMMY FLOYD FEED AND DILATE SUCK SNEED SEETHE DILATE CITY SLICKER CHUCK HOT POCKETS I CAN’T CHUCK’S AND COPE DILATE SNEED’S DILATE HOT POCKETS FEED I CAN’T HOT POCKETS CITY SLICKER SNEED CHUCK FUCK COPE SNEED’S CLEAN IT UP AND DILATE CHUCK’S SUCK SNEED FEED CITY SLICKER AND SNEED ON LEMMY SEED FEED AND

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

CLEAN IT UP SEED FUCK SNEED CITY SLICKER JANNY JANNY SNEED CHUCK’S SNEED’S JANNY FEED SNEED SNEED’S SUCK FEED HOT POCKETS JANNY SEED CLEAN IT UP SEETHE FUCK CITY SLICKER FUCK CITY SLICKER SUCK SNEED’S CHUCK’S ON LEMMY SNEED CLEAN IT UP SNEED’S I CAN’T FUCK HOT POCKETS JANNIES FOR FREE CLEAN IT UP JANNIES SEETHE SUCK SEETHE SEETHE FOR FREE FEED SUCK FUCK HOT POCKETS SEETHE FEED

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

JANNIES CHUCK’S I CAN’T SNEED’S AND COPE AND FEED SNEED JANNY CHUCK’S DILATE CHUCK’S SUCK CHUCK SNEED’S CLEAN IT UP CITY SLICKER I CAN’T FEED SUCK CHUCK ON LEMMY FLOYD HOT POCKETS AND SEED DILATE COPE FOR FREE CLEAN IT UP I CAN’T SEETHE HOT POCKETS JANNY FUCK CHUCK’S ON LEMMY SUCK CHUCK’S CITY SLICKER FEED CITY SLICKER DILATE SEETHE FEED FOR FREE SEETHE DILATE SEETHE

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

ThuleanPerspective2,

FLOYD CITY SLICKER ON LEMMY I CAN’T FLOYD FEED CHUCK’S JANNIES JANNY CLEAN IT UP SEETHE FUCK CHUCK SNEED’S I CAN’T AND CITY SLICKER CITY SLICKER I CAN’T HOT POCKETS JANNY JANNY DILATE SNEED CHUCK SNEED SEED ON LEMMY SNEED CHUCK’S FEED SUCK CHUCK ON LEMMY JANNIES CITY SLICKER CITY SLICKER COPE CITY SLICKER JANNY JANNIES SNEED’S SUCK COPE FLOYD DILATE CHUCK CHUCK SUCK DILATE

https://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d0f23042-9f46-42fb-86bd-2a08538c6bc1.pnghttps://lemmygrad.ml/pictrs/image/d89a4c13-1e16-4021-a5af-08927279297b.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961305917656.pnghttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961306111010.gifhttps://czchan.org/uploads/1710961307845375.png

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • canada@lemmy.ca
  • slotface
  • kavyap
  • thenastyranch
  • everett
  • tacticalgear
  • rosin
  • Durango
  • DreamBathrooms
  • mdbf
  • magazineikmin
  • InstantRegret
  • Youngstown
  • khanakhh
  • ethstaker
  • JUstTest
  • ngwrru68w68
  • cisconetworking
  • modclub
  • tester
  • osvaldo12
  • cubers
  • GTA5RPClips
  • normalnudes
  • Leos
  • provamag3
  • anitta
  • megavids
  • lostlight
  • All magazines