I'm really enjoying no down votes on Beehaw

When I first found out it was an interesting concept that I was pretty neutral on but the more I engage/lurk with the community the more I enjoy it.

I generally don't post/comment much on Reddit because I tend to be extremely sincere and that's not always well received. Usually I don't get much hate, but what I do get is a lot of non-interaction mixed with downvotes. And it's just really discouraging when I'm just trying to share my thoughts.

But having no downvotes here is so nice because I'm not afraid that I'm going to get silenced into oblivion. Either people will actually engage with me (and maybe disagree, but in a meaningful way), or they'll move on and not randomly share their disdain via downvoting.

It's such a small change but makes a big difference. I bet a lot of people feel the same as me - it's more comfortable to engage here.

apis,

deleted_by_author

    •
    Kwakigra,

    The only reason I used the downvote on Reddit was if someone was being anti-social, such as racism or any other ism or just general jerkishness for no good reason. I haven't seen any of that yet here. When I do I'll call it out.

    j4k3,
    @j4k3@lemmy.world avatar

    The down vote visibility should be a user settings option for everyone IMO

    awfulsystems,

    I’ve already seen (and reported) some anti-trans bigotry on here, but it had more upvotes than the posts calling it out for what it was because the bigotry was of the “polite and pretending to be well-researched” variety

    without downvotes as a tool against crap like that, what have we got? is it against our instance’s “be nice” policy to tell nazi punks to fuck off?

    Hotchpotch, (edited )

    I've seen a lot of toxic crap upvoted on reddit. Personally i prefer moderation over public vote any day.

    balderdash9,

    Both options are non-ideal. Some mods are on a power trip and public opinion can vary wildly depending on the thread/community

    LimitedBrain,

    I will say, public vote is sometimes nice because you can more easily understand the values of a community through the voting.

    alyaza,
    @alyaza@beehaw.org avatar

    without downvotes as a tool against crap like that, what have we got? is it against our instance’s “be nice” policy to tell nazi punks to fuck off?

    nope! we're not going to ban for telling a TERF or nazi to eat shit or whatever. we as admins do try to be nice where possible, but you as a user really aren't obligated to be because that's dumb lol. you can also report it to us and in general we dispatch users who are like that as possible (although sidenote: if it's a post off-instance and you report it, unless the user is really, really bad we probably won't do anything immediately because we just can't keep an eye on every possible bad actor.)

    meteorswarm,

    Thanks for clarifying!

    I've been super impressed by moderation so far. This morning I saw a post justifying sexism because of Bible verses and by the time I'd mustered a reply it was gone, to my delight.

    jrubal1462,

    That's nice to see. When I first saw the policy of having no downvotes, I wondered if that would leave no recourse against trolls and scumbags, but I guess strong moderation is the key.

    I probably wouldn't want the entire internet to be so strongly moderated, but I'm really glad there are some popular places that are. Thanks for doing that.

    ABlackWaltz,

    The admins have taken a stance where this should be a safe space and those being insulted/harassed/discriminated against are welcome to respond in kind. The most important part is to report it so the mods/admins can review and take action as needed.

    While it may not be nice to tell nazi punks to fuck off, it will ultimately make for a nicer community if they do - we don't mind community members saying "hey, this isn't cool" in whatever manner they feel necessary.

    awfulsystems,

    I’m glad that’s the case! it alleviates a lot of my worries around recommending beehaw to my LGBT+ friends

    Lowbird,

    I've had similar worries, but overall I'm coming around to the idea that for cases of bigotry it's better to just report the bigot and maybe also yell at them (which is allowed) than to put it to a public vote and hope that lands them at -200 downvotes or whatever. Not being able to downvote them stings a bit, but if they get reported and booted reliably, I think it's worth the tradeoff.

    Especially since reddit definitely had the same problem in a lot of cases anyway. Sometimes, in some subreddits, transphobia would be downvoted. But in others, the """polite""" or even blatantly not "polite" transphobia would be upvoted. Sometimes even in places where I didn't expect it.

    (looking at you, gaming subreddits mad about some trans people asking you not to buy a wizard game, jesus. That ~2 weeks was hell on the internet. And meanwhile, posts calling for people not to pre-order games, or to boycott games that have microtransactions - those are acceptable and go right to the top, apparently! Ugh.)

    Edit: ditto for the similar problem of "" polite"" biotruths-styles sexism and racism.

    ABlackWaltz,

    I highly recommend reviewing this post from Gaywallet: https://beehaw.org/post/107014. Specifically, the Spirit of Beehaw and What is (and isn't) Beehaw. These sections go into what I paraphrased above at length, if you want the admin's full thoughts.

    boredtortoise,

    It doesn't seem to work correctly — yet(?). Beehaw users can't downvote anywhere. Other users can downvote on beehaw.

    Intention is probably that downvotes are not available only on beehaw for anyone.

    alyaza,
    @alyaza@beehaw.org avatar

    It doesn’t seem to work correctly — yet(?). Beehaw users can’t downvote anywhere. Other users can downvote on beehaw.

    the global downvoting disable is a byproduct of how toggling downvotes off works with federation: since you access other instances through browsing us, the current implementation can't distinguish where we end and another instance begins. this might eventually get fixed but it's at worst an inconvenience. downvotes meanwhile don't register from anywhere--if a downvote looks like it works, it doesn't actually. nothing happens.

    boredtortoise,

    Thanks for the clarification!

    NekomimiNebula,

    That's my same thought too, on Reddit you're always scared of "saying the wrong thing" because your fake internet points will go down

    god,
    @god@sh.itjust.works avatar

    omg i can troll now no downvotes omg nice!

    dan1101,
    @dan1101@lemmy.world avatar

    I just downvoted you. But you can't see it bwahahaha!!

    god,
    @god@sh.itjust.works avatar

    i'm not on beehaw tho, i could see it, if it had federated correctly, but it seems it hasn't cuz: https://sh.itjust.works/pictrs/image/9f7c7db6-7efc-4341-96a7-5b7d6e866758.png

    FlowerTree,
    @FlowerTree@pawb.social avatar

    You can, but that doesn't make it consequence free. You know that bans exist, especially for a more egregious trolls.

    god,
    @god@sh.itjust.works avatar

    omg i can't troll ill get banned sad sad :C

    hydra,
    @hydra@lemmy.world avatar

    The good thing is the karma system is no longer here to torment you. You also won't be shadowbanned for arbitrary reasons like on Reddit. I personally do prefer downvotes to use them against bad faith discourse or trolls (there was a user posting female scat pics on random communities in lemmy.world)

    loops,

    Now we have infinite fake internet points.

    god,
    @god@sh.itjust.works avatar

    can we even see how many points we have tho

    Lowbird,

    We can even hide the fake internet points!

    I like see my little piles of upvotes though. But maybe it's bad because ultimately it means I'm giving importance to the external validation of strangers, and the flipside of that is being easily affected by downvotes too. It might be better to hide scores (in profile settings). But I also kinda don't want to because it shows someone read my comment/post and I didn't waste my time, even if nobody replies.

    Ataraxia,
    @Ataraxia@lemmy.world avatar

    What's funny is that I see that people down voted you for that comment.

    I never cared about karma on reddit so I just said what I wanted and didn't care. Here, so far, haven't dealt with anyone just being randomly aggressive for no reason so, at least I hope, my comments have been fairly neutral.

    https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/72062eb9-d173-4c97-9087-3ddd18833e05.jpeg

    kuchaibee,

    The initial intent of reddit was to have downvotes be for off topic stuff, and yet most people use it as a silent "your opinion sucks" button. That stuff just adds to the hivemind feel of reddit. I wish there was a way to have an alternative system of weeding out misinformation or rude stuff without having to deal with something like downvotes. I suppose moderation could serve the purpose of weeding out the bad stuff instead, but then each community would need to be moderated properly.

    ByteSorcerer,

    An old forum I used to frequent had a downvote system that required you to specify a reason for why you felt that post or comment required a downvote. That reason (and the account that submitted it) was visible to the person whose post got downvoted and to the moderators, but to no one else.

    It still worked well for filtering out troll posts and spam, and legit posts were almost never downvoted as you couldn't do so fully anonymously and moderators could take action when you abused the system.

    I could see this becoming highly impractical when communities become as huge as on Reddit though, but for a smaller forum that one had a few hundred active users it worked really well.

    Lowbird,

    That... Sounds fantastic, actually. Although I could see people just generating puppet accounts to send harassing messages that only the victim and mods see, and switching accounts when they get banned. Could go especially bad in situations where the mods are also kinda in on it, as can happen (see also: organizations that turn out to have been "secretly" openly racist all along, in a way that was invisible to white workers but blatant to black workers, and that kind of thing).

    tango_octogono,
    @tango_octogono@beehaw.org avatar

    That’s actually genious

    balderdash9,

    Some subreddits managed to do it when the topic was very specific and the mods were dedicated. I'm thinking of r/AskHistorians and r/Askphilosophy

    fcuks,

    I like the hackernews approach where downvotes on comments aren't seen, the comments are just faded out. The more downvotes = the more invisible it is.

    Also thought this could be a cool approach with nice side effects - https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2023/jun/social-media-trustdistrust-buttons-could-reduce-spread-misinformation

    Lowbird,

    That sounds kinda awful to me, because it could be used to just disappear unpopular comments complaining of racism or transphobia or whatever, or even just to disappear a comment saying "I hated this really popular game actually because xyz". It sounds like something that would exaggerate the hivemind effect of downvotes rather than alleviating it, and probably be used to silence even justifiably angry or emphatic comments, if now you can't even see the few comments that disagreed with the majority in a thread.

    KrimsonBun,
    @KrimsonBun@lemmy.ml avatar

    Honestly I like the idea of downvotes, but the way the reddit community has implemented them is just toxic. But that's the great thing about Lemmy and the fediverse: Don't like it? Go to an instance that's disabled it!

    Mindless_Enigma,
    @Mindless_Enigma@beehaw.org avatar

    If downvotes had been used as originally intended, they would be perfectly fine. But the cultural shift over time on the site from "downvote things not adding to the conversation" to "downvote what I don't agree with" made their existence more toxic to conversations. Weighing down unpopular opinions in the sort feed made it even easier for echo chambers to build up. Having a way to give comments that are productive a bump is enough for effectively sorting things.

    lackthought,
    @lackthought@lemmy.sdf.org avatar

    I unchecked the 'Show Scores' option in settings (desktop site) and I enjoy the experience a lot

    feels like old school forums where people just communicated instead of all this useless gamification

    anji,

    This is one reason why I like it here. What annoyed me on Reddit sometimes was discussing "unpopular opinions".

    For example on my local subreddit people would constantly argue for more housing density, which is great for affordability but any mention of "but what about transportation infrastructure then" got mercilessly downvoted. I really don't mind people disagreeing in replies but having a whole conversation downvoted and subsequently hidden is annoying. It generally made me not want to comment on Reddit, and just let the hivemind be.

    CrimsonOnoscopy,

    I do wish there was another way to hide posts. I don't want to upvote everything.

    brunofin,

    You've got a point. I was bothered with no downvotes until your post and it's true, we are free to actually have open conversations here instead of be received with being downvoted. Cool!

    fcuks,

    haha not that you should care, but guess you can be downvoted via other instances.

    https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/44c49589-6167-4b3d-acde-1118ff1bc78c.jpeg

    Lowbird,

    You can't - it'll look like your downvote went through on your side, when you downvote from another instance, but it doesn't actually show up for anyone else or change the comment score.

    fcuks,

    i didn't downvote bro that was just what was there

    bathcat,

    Yeah, but what do I do to get that little rush of self-satisfaction from down voting a comment I disagree with? /s

    In all seriousness, it may require a little more diligence from community mods to police comments which violate beehaw community standards since they won't fall to the bottom or be hidden as fast.

    DreamySweet,

    The lack of voting is why I still prefer forums over reddit-style sites. Voting, both up and down, stifles discussion and encourages repetative meme comments for upvotes.

    I remember a reddit thread from years ago where a guy was trying to deal with a spider infestation in his car and almost every reply was a variation of "kill them with fire" or "it belongs to the spiders now". Many comments were made by different people at the same time with the exact same wording. The guy got almost no serious replies. I don't think that would have happened without the culture created by the voting system.

    Hammy,

    I guess I'm the only one that misses downvotes. I don't take offense to being downvoted - the points/karma is completely irrelevant and I feel like it helps keep unhelpful or irrelevant comments and content at the bottom and out of my feed.

    bug,

    Yeah, my concern is that the trolls will be just as visible as the recent comments, and that we'll get overloaded with "take my upvote", "this is the way", and "nice" comments which are essentially spam

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • chat@beehaw.org
  • ngwrru68w68
  • rosin
  • GTA5RPClips
  • osvaldo12
  • love
  • Youngstown
  • slotface
  • khanakhh
  • everett
  • kavyap
  • mdbf
  • DreamBathrooms
  • thenastyranch
  • magazineikmin
  • anitta
  • InstantRegret
  • normalnudes
  • tacticalgear
  • cubers
  • ethstaker
  • modclub
  • cisconetworking
  • Durango
  • provamag3
  • tester
  • Leos
  • megavids
  • JUstTest
  • All magazines
    •