@JPEGuin Probably not directly your issue, but I come to your site and see 9 icons that mean nothing to me and have to mouse over each one to even figure out whether any of these are things that would be of use to me.
Maybe find a design where you can show the names right away?
And pet peeve: Since a lot of the names mean nothing to me, what about adding a byline that gives me an idea. Like “Vinyls - your record and CD database” (or whatever it does). Make that web site scannable.