Is NZ bringing in 'Indonesian coal every month to keep the lights on'?

Analysis: Burning less coal to make electricity helped New Zealand achieve its biggest official annual drop in planet-heating gases since records started in 1990.

The same week those figures came out, Resources Minister Shane Jones told Morning Report New Zealand should develop more of its own coal, rather than importing “dirty” coal from Indonesia.

Jones earlier told Parliament that opposition MPs turned a blind eye while New Zealand imported Indonesian coal “every month, to keep the lights on.”

While it’s true Genesis Energy - owner of the country’s only coal-fired station - burns coal to run its Huntly generators, it last year reported that its last shipment of coal had arrived in July 2022.

Government figures show New Zealand was a net exporter of coal every year since records began, except 2021 - a dry year for hydro, coupled with an unexpected shortage on Genesis’ gas field.

That was the year Huntly used record amounts of imported Indonesian coal, pushing up the climate impact of the whole country.

deadbeef79000,

Like all headlines that ask a question the answer is “no”, other wise the headline would state that fact.

Dave,
@Dave@lemmy.nz avatar

With these political analysis pieces from RNZ where they investigate a claim from a politician, some of them the answer is actually yes, what they said is close enough to true. But it’s pretty rare, to say the least.

deadbeef79000,

Sometines yeah, but all headline questions are pure click bait.

“Minister’s claims of imported Indonesian coal false” is the appropriate headline.

I’d even argue that the country of origin is irrelevant and serves only to stoke some anti-asia sentiment.

Dave,
@Dave@lemmy.nz avatar

You’re probably right, but I’d argue it was the minister rather than RNZ trying to stoke that sentiment though.

deadbeef79000,

A very important distinction. TYVM.

kaffiene,

I love seeing discussions on Mastodon where people actually debate issues in such a constructive, informative manner. This is why I love it here

liv,
@liv@lemmy.nz avatar

Yeah nah, country of origin is important.

To people interested in the environment the phrase “Indonesian coal” tells us two things really quickly.

Firstly, that it comes from an industry that’s deforesting, killing orangutans etc. The Indonesian mining sector is open cast, meaning they tear up the rainforest to get at the coal. Obviously you can’t remediate that, not that they try hard, and it pollutes, causes flooding, and destroys livelihoods as well.

Secondly, Indonesia’s coal is sub-bituminous. That’s a crappy low grade kind of coal that releases way more greenhouse gasses than high grade coal.

Edit: Shane Jones might well be trying to use racist overtones like you and @Dave said, I’m just saying calling it “Indonesian coal” isn’t inherently race whistling.

deadbeef79000,

Thank you for that detail. I was aware that coal’s qualities differ from region to region (hence Huntly not burning NZ coal). But was ignorant of what regions’ qualities are.

In that context yeah, country or origin is an effective short-hand.

TagMeInSkipIGotThis,

The short answer is basically that the Resource Minister lied, likely not for the first time and an increasingly consistent theme from this government’s ministers. If it continues the appropriate response from media would be to publish no comments from these ministers without fact checking and correcting in the original story.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • politics@lemmy.nz
  • PowerRangers
  • DreamBathrooms
  • thenastyranch
  • magazineikmin
  • mdbf
  • Youngstown
  • osvaldo12
  • slotface
  • everett
  • rosin
  • hgfsjryuu7
  • kavyap
  • tsrsr
  • ngwrru68w68
  • Leos
  • khanakhh
  • cisconetworking
  • modclub
  • GTA5RPClips
  • Durango
  • InstantRegret
  • vwfavf
  • tacticalgear
  • tester
  • cubers
  • ethstaker
  • normalnudes
  • anitta
  • All magazines
    •