Thinking about expectations after I came across some negative reviews of #StarWars The Acolyte. I like it so far … but I also loved the original trilogy.
See, when the 2nd trilogy came out, I felt it was just terrible. (That hasn't changed, everything hinges on Padme falling in love with that little kid, which holy fuck just no.)
The 3rd trilogy I did watch but I found it utterly forgettable. The Filoni shows tend to start out good but then just make everything feel small and mere fan service.
Now, for the first time in a long time, a new #StarWars show comes along that tries to do something different. No empire, no stormtroopers, no known characters, and I have no idea where the show is going. And nobody else seems to know because that time period is uncharted territory so far or something? That's pretty exciting to me!
The last time I felt this excited about a SW story was with Andor (an adult show, no fan service!) and Bioware's original KoTOR (4000 years earlier!). Everything …
Blank slate, kind of! And it showed a universe that has so much room for … well, anything! Because #StarWars shouldn’t be “Six degrees of Kevin Skywalker”, IMHO. I don't need the origin story of some rando who was in the same cantina as Han back on Tatooine, instead give me some fresh stuff.
Acolyte is enticing because I don't know where it'll end up, lore-wise. Maybe it turns out to be shit, sure, but it's not Formula Disney (yet?).
SW, man. So much potential, yet so much risk-averseness.
I’m not really sure where this is headed. But I guess it’s ok so far. I recall feeling iffy about The Mandalotian at first too, but it eventually won me over.
Also.... I made the mistake of reading comments on various posts made by Disney/Star Wars for #TheAcolyte and holy shit, some people are the actual WORST. Some people must live just for shitting on things or other people.
Look at the Rotten Tomatoes score, critics are very high, audience is very low. Like damn, nobody likes to hate on things they love more than some #StarWars fans it would seem...
Und wer von euch hat schon #theacolyte auf Disney+ angeschaut?
Wir (Sohn2 und ich) haben uns heute die ersten beiden Episoden gegeben und finden es interessant.
Was denkt ihr? #starwars
Lee Jung-jae as Master Sol is great. I think this will be the most memorable character from #TheAcolyte which #StarWars fans will love for years to come.
Watched the second episode of #TheAcolyte and it is still ok. The second episode was a bit better than the first, enjoyed the alien designs and the city and all that. The story moves forward with every episode so far, compared to #Ahsoka this is lightning fast. And I prefer that much more, the show doesn’t keep you hanging, it always solves some plot points and sets up new. I‘d still prefer this whole thing to be a movie, a proper #StarWars movie, remember those?
@stpaultim For me movies just hit different. And especially with Star Wars it's such a big screen event thing. The shows are so-so (Andor and all the animated stuff is good to great, the rest varies wildly for me) and the use of the Volume in most of them makes them all look a bit dull.
I watched The Acolyte last night, and forgot to share about it here!
Spoiler-free first impressions thread:
• I really like this era. 100 years before Episode III is close enough to the prequels to feel much more like them than anything else, but also, the Jedi are more at their peak than even then.
• So far there have been no references to or appearances of characters or planets that we know besides Coruscant. And I’m okay with this.
Spoiler-free impressions of The Acolyte, continued:
• I don’t think I felt the need/want to explain context or lore to others watching—refreshing after Ahsoka (which I also really enjoyed, to be fair, but for different reasons!)
• Okay yeah we have Nemoidians and Coruscant and Jedi with the Force and lightsabers and hyperspace… it is still 100% Star Wars
• I appreciate that it jives with The High Republic era aesthetically but that’s about it
Spoiler-free impressions of The Acolyte, continued:
• I want more! That’s a good thing. I remember so many people dogged on Andor for starting out slow, but it had to take its time to introduce you to the state of the galaxy, the characters, the motivations. This doesn’t feel as slow-burn (or as deep) as Andor, but just remember the first impressions of that show before you judge this one too hard from its premier. 😉