futurebird, (edited )
@futurebird@sauropods.win avatar

Which of the following do you consider to be "bugs"

"Bug" is not a scientific clade, or well-defined group. So, there are probably no wrong answers.

Check all that apply!

elysegrasso,
@elysegrasso@historians.social avatar

@futurebird A, none of the above
B. That's mussels, not muscles: spell checker being overly helpful?

FeralRobots,
@FeralRobots@mastodon.social avatar

@futurebird my brother the entomologist has always classified certain insects as "true bugs", but I forget what clade he's referring to when he says that. Also I gather the classification is kind of an in-joke among entomologists. (Not that he'd ever admit that. There are things he deadpanned about when we were kids, decades ago, that he only now comes clean on, & "true bugs" has become a running joke with his kids so I imagine he'll carry that one to his grave.)

JeffreyJDean,

@futurebird
None of the above. To me, bugs are insects. The exception that proves the rule is sow bugs / pill bugs / woodlice, which are actually crustaceans. But arachnids, scorpions, marine crustaceans, and other non-insectile arthropods are NOT bugs.

Tattie,

@futurebird in this household we refer to shrimp and prawns as "fishybugs". 🦐 :blobcat_smirk:

SpeakerToManagers,
@SpeakerToManagers@wandering.shop avatar

@futurebird
None of the above. Earthworm, tardigrades, and muscles & clams aren’t even in the phylum Arthropoda, and while lobsters etc are, they’re not in the class Insecta, where I would put all the bugs.

nimbledaemon,
nimbledaemon avatar

@futurebird Not completely sea/water dwelling invertebrates, or resembling such things even if it is completely sea/water dwelling, with lobsters, crabs, and shrimp specifically not being bugs. This probably makes no scientific sense, but is how I would label them.

CEvaN,

@futurebird I use it as a synonym for 'insect' except when I'm talking about vertebrate pets who are 'bugs' but the etymology is different cause they 'bug people for attention ' in an endearing way, ofc.

However, I wouldn't be averse to equating 'bug' to all hexapods, largely because I can never remember the rest of the clade, lol

justafrog,
@justafrog@mstdn.social avatar

@futurebird Really anything under arthropoda is "bugs" to me.

Everything not in that order makes about as much sense to me as calling a banana a mammal. Those are all not bugs.

degreesOfFreedom,

@futurebird I really only use "bug" for insects, but that's not an option and the poll won't let me vote without checking at least one category.

goaty,

@futurebird to me, a "bug" has to be a have paired legs and a segmented body, so tardigrade and those crustaceans are "bugs" but worms and molluscs aren't

Andrew,

@goaty I'm totally on the same page. I didn't grow up eating crustaceans so from an outsiders perspective they just looked like sea bugs to me. I'll eat them today, but they're still bugs in my book!

npdemers,
@npdemers@mastodon.social avatar

@futurebird I think I peg anything with lots of legs and an exoskeleton as "bug".

jf_718,
@jf_718@mas.to avatar

@futurebird None of the above.

barrygoldman1,
@barrygoldman1@sauropods.win avatar

@futurebird bugs r jointy, crawl, smaller than thumb, and big enough to tell by naked eye that they crawl and are jointy, so not tardis and really really tiny mites. spiders count.

if i grew up on the ocean MAYBE i'd consider crustacea bugs, not sure.

other land arthropds like pill bugs and centipedes ok.

baby toads are ALMOST bugs. monarch butterflies are NOT.

Stegosaurus,

@futurebird I'm sorry - I didn't find mosquito. There must be a bug in the system! 😄

PTR_K,
@PTR_K@dice.camp avatar

@futurebird
Since undergrad biology, I've tried to limit the term to hemiptera. (Ladybugs and pillbugs are grandfathered exceptions.)

Prior to that, I would have described all insects and a few land-based arthropods, as bugs.

#arthropods #insects

EeveeEuphoria,

@futurebird none of those are bugs

however, horses are

StellaFoxxie,

@futurebird if it lives in water its no longer a bug imo, even if they are closely related to their land dwelling buggy counterparts

there are exceptions to this of course, but that is the generally how i feel about it

Daniel_Berky,

@futurebird That would, er, be “mussels”, but I digress. I don't consider anything on the available choice as 'bugs'

laescude,

@futurebird I don’t eat bugs, so if I eat them, they are automatically no longer bugs in my book. I declassified some critters while travelling in Mexico.

petep44,
@petep44@syringa.social avatar

@futurebird In my worldview, NONE of these qualify as bugs. There’s my vote.

marc_w,
@marc_w@union.place avatar

@futurebird

None of those are bugs.

joelvanderwerf,
@joelvanderwerf@mastodon.social avatar

@futurebird Saying this to myself for each choice. (But krill are definitely bugs.)

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • ethstaker
  • DreamBathrooms
  • cubers
  • osvaldo12
  • mdbf
  • magazineikmin
  • normalnudes
  • InstantRegret
  • rosin
  • Youngstown
  • slotface
  • khanakhh
  • kavyap
  • ngwrru68w68
  • JUstTest
  • everett
  • cisconetworking
  • tacticalgear
  • anitta
  • thenastyranch
  • Durango
  • tester
  • GTA5RPClips
  • modclub
  • megavids
  • provamag3
  • Leos
  • lostlight
  • All magazines