Signal Essay about CIA ties and anti-FOSS

We as a community must stop recommending Signal. For far too long we have blindly followed this app without a second thought. It has created a cult of followers, when there are much better apps out there for us to use.

https://archive.is/Lhe24 archive for the essay

This essay was posted to r/Privacy and subsequently removed and censored for literally No Reason. This is honestly really scary: https://old.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/wj5svi/signal_messenger_revealed_to_have_cia_ties_funded/ https://archive.ph/FZr1d

I am seriously hoping we can have a discussion about this on lemmy. @TheAnonymouseJoker , I know you from r/PrivateLife, and thought you'd be the one to go to about this. Thanks for being open in the past and not bowing to the inner circle of reddit cringelords.

I also am preparing an essay of my own about a complicit honeypot-ish web going on between Signal, Skiff, r/Privacy, r/PrivacyGuides, etc. They have a crazy little cabal that is very creepy. Any materials are welcome. Every time i turn over a stone i find two more. More to come.

LollerCorleone,
LollerCorleone avatar

Governments routinely fund the development of secure and open communication systems because they themselves benefit from having such communication tools which can be trusted. By the logic presented in this "essay", one shouldn't be using the internet at all. What you need to check is whether Signal's technical claims about its encryption is true or not. There is nothing in this article that raises any question on Signal's encryption. We already know how much data Signal has on its users through their responses to various legal subpoenas over the years (spoiler: its pretty much nothing).

Here are some cool links for you to check out:
https://signal.org/bigbrother/
https://www.aclu.org/news/national-security/new-documents-reveal-government-effort-impose-secrecy-encryption

hillbicks,

Thanks, was about to post the same. I have no emotional attachment to signal, but I haven't seen a real reason why I shouldn't be using it anymore. At least from a security point of view. It works very reliably for years now and does most of the things i expect from it.

LollerCorleone,
LollerCorleone avatar

Yep! Signal is the only decent privacy-oriented messaging app available right now, which can also be used easily the non-techy masses.

Unlucky_Boot3467,

false

bernard,

When Signal is compromised or compelled, you won't know it happened. It may have happened already.

Unlucky_Boot3467,

The dodge-and-cope is real lol

LollerCorleone,
LollerCorleone avatar

Looking from your response to my comment, it certainly looks like it!

PM_ME_UR_PCAPS,

Signal haters are back. I skimmed it and didn’t see anything remotely convincing or new. I was hoping this lemmy community wouldn’t turn into quite the level of deranged conspiracy posting as the subreddit of the same name, but it looks like that may not be the case.

Unlucky_Boot3467,

The evidence is all there. It's ironic that the negative association of the word "conspiracy" was actually pushed by the CIA and their cohorts, and is used on other words too, to cause your mind to instantly recoil is disassociate yourself from it.

Just try it. Say "I'm a conspiracy theorist" out loud in front of people, and felt the fear instantly take over as you try to mentally remove yourself from it. That's called brainwashing.

But people like you do their bidding and perpetuate the weaponization of "evil" sounding words.

LollerCorleone,
LollerCorleone avatar

" The evidence is all there."

They aren't though.

amanneedsamaid,

What a weird response, three paragraphs and absolutely 0 relevant information.

!deleted125603,

deleted_by_author

    •
    Unlucky_Boot3467,

    To be sure, your messages won't be read from the server, but that's not the point. There's way more going on.

    sourcery,

    How exactly is Signal anti-FOSS? This might have been a problem before (the article is from 2021) but I checked the Github link in the article and the server was updated 18 hours ago with frequent updates this year alone. I also find the source of funding argument to be pretty flimsy. Though I do agree with the conclusion that federated alternatives are better for privacy. For my personal threat model Signal is fine for me.

    No hate though, it's an interesting read, I'd like to see more discussions like this.

    Unlucky_Boot3467,

    They are extremely begrudging when it comes to providing a fully FOSS apk. They push really hard for their app to be pulled from Google's servers and refuse to do an F-Droid build or even set up their own instance where they can push whatever they want.

    sourcery,

    There are legitimate reasons for not wanting to use Fdroid and their builds are apparently reproducible, not sure what you mean about not being fully FOSS either. https://signal.org/blog/reproducible-android/

    fogetaboutit,

    There are legitimate reasons for not wanting to use Fdroid

    Such as?

    sourcery,

    Some developers don't like their key signing process.

    bernard,

    The client app is FOSS other than the Google blob for notifications. The server SW is partly closed source because they say that is needed to prevent spammers.

    Fickle_Ferret,
    @Fickle_Ferret@lemmy.ml avatar

    Thank you for posting archive links

    Unlucky_Boot3467,

    No problem. I wanna make sure they can't delete anything. Save PDFs of all top tier webpages and essays too!

    amanneedsamaid,

    Lmao you’re getting downvotes for the most innocuous possible comment.

    pabloscloud,
    @pabloscloud@lemmy.world avatar

    Ok, so what is better with other apps and why shouldn't one recommend signal over the apps people use (say Whatsapp, telegram)

    Unlucky_Boot3467,

    It's up to you, but you gotta ask yourself. Do you want to use a messaging app that forces Google, phone numbers, and has ties to the CIA? No thanks! Also, anyone with access to your text messages can take over your Signal account. Including the Feds ofc

    gonzo0815,

    OP linked a whole essay about the second part of your question.

    An alternative would be matrix, which can be used with the elements app on your phone.

    pabloscloud,
    @pabloscloud@lemmy.world avatar

    Sorry, I only clicked the archive link but that's the broken one 😂

    pabloscloud,
    @pabloscloud@lemmy.world avatar

    And also fluffychat has a much better ui in my opinion

    jmp242,

    Doesn't matrix massively inncrease the number of entities you have to trust with the data and so more places it could be attacked? I. E. Kind of like RAID0 your places for something to go wrong in the message routing and storage.

    Matrix seems way more like a Discord alternative where you are doing public group chats vs like xmpp or signal point to point sms sort of chat.

    PM_ME_UR_PCAPS,

    Matrix, where it’s ambiguous if you’re sending encrypted or unencrypted messages, disappearing and view once messages aren’t really a thing, and the server logs all metatata. Much better than signal.

    Vendetta9076,
    @Vendetta9076@sh.itjust.works avatar

    To be fair, all of that stuff can be controlled by the server host. Too bad you have to be the server host to be sure.

    bernard,

    Even if Signal might be better for those people's current threat model, people's habits are hard to change. Good luck getting them onto a better decentralized protocol later. Most people will not take the time to understand the importance of decentralization and think we are just making their lives difficult. I regret getting people onto Signal mainly for this reason.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • privacy@lemmy.ml
  • kavyap
  • thenastyranch
  • GTA5RPClips
  • tester
  • InstantRegret
  • DreamBathrooms
  • ngwrru68w68
  • magazineikmin
  • everett
  • Youngstown
  • mdbf
  • slotface
  • rosin
  • cisconetworking
  • megavids
  • khanakhh
  • normalnudes
  • osvaldo12
  • cubers
  • tacticalgear
  • Durango
  • ethstaker
  • modclub
  • anitta
  • provamag3
  • Leos
  • JUstTest
  • lostlight
  • All magazines
    •