@KathyReid@aus.social
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

KathyReid

@KathyReid@aus.social

Doing a #PhD https://aus.social/@anucybernetics in #opensource #voice and #data #bias #FairML. Into #linux, #IoT. Built @SenseBreast. She/her pronouns. Ex @mycroft_ai https://fosstodon.org/@linuxaustralia @deakin @mozilla
Living in Australia on Waddawurrung land but with connections in #Northumberland
#MastoAdmin for fediverse.au

This profile is from a federated server and may be incomplete. Browse more on the original instance.

KathyReid, to microsoft
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

Why does want to implement ? It's not about images. It's about modelling what workers do on Windows, and then replacing them.

The most expensive part of a computer is the fallible feelings-filled unpredictable meat sack that operates it.

Google has YouTube, Google Photos, Maps, and a bucket load of search data, Google Analytics, advertising, as well as it's data (e.g. transcriptions). And a bunch of data from Android services. From this data they can model speech, model videos and model advertising systems, and how humans respond to them.

But they can't model what people do on computers.

Amazon has Prime data, and a bucket load of compute. But no operating system data. They can build models based around e-commerce and advertising systems.

But they can't model what people do on computers.

Meta has waves hands enough analytics to model human behaviour in the Metaverse.

But they can't model what people do on computers.

Microsoft has GitHub.
Microsoft has LinkedIn.
Microsoft has SharePoint.
Microsoft has Teams.
Microsoft has Dynamics.
Microsoft has O365.
Microsoft has Windows telemetry data.

Microsoft can model what people do on (Windows) computers. Like fill out spreadsheets.Write emails. Synthesize web pages of research. Interact with colleagues on Teams. Create and edit documents.

Microsoft wants data so they can model what people do with operating systems.

Then replace them.

Imagine a CoPilot that doesn't just write buggy code. Imagine one that also does spreadsheets. That creates documents on SharePoint. That communicates with colleages on Teams. That has a customer pipeline on Dynamics.

That's what Recall is about - 360 degree surveillance of the worker, to model their functions, make them fungible, replicable - and replaceable.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@adamsteer exactly - all the while consuming fresh water, increasing the need for energy and kicking the can to the next generation.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@adamsteer I would literally pay real fiat money to watch this.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@milesmcbain yes 100%

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@ralfmaximus My thinking is that you don't need the raw data in the cloud if you do federated learning ...

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@rasterweb @vitriolix More Embrace, Extend, Enshittify, Extinguish

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@xchange exactly

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@miki have you heard of federated learning?

jessie, to random
@jessie@mastodon.social avatar

Friends, Romans, fellow internet nerds: Do we have resources we like for teaching R to already-competent developers?

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@jessie Hey Jess try the hashtag

adamsteer, to random
@adamsteer@mapstodon.space avatar

It's job application weekend again with 5 weeks on the current clock. It is painful. there's nothing that really "fits" skills or location (Bendigo, Victoria, Australia). No permanent roles, all short term.

If you want to headhunt a highly trained, super experienced, skilled researcher and geospatial data analyst, who can lead teams and develop concepts from dream to strategy to reality to results, and is trusted to get remote work done - reach out! Save me and my referees a pile of effort.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@adamsteer hey Adam, also use hashtags to find roles - lots of bots looks for these tags.

KathyReid, to random
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

Sam Altman has recently suggested as an alternative to .

Apart from being egregiously out of touch, it's also a huge power move, one that I don't think people grasp.

The polarisation of society into those deriving an income from return on capital - capitalists - and those deriving an income from labour - workers - has been driven in large part by venture capital and their hunger for new asset classes.

Housing is an asset class, it's no longer social infrastructure.

Stocks are an asset class - they're no longer a way to ensure survival of the best organisations - because many companies with little revenue have high valuations.

Compute is now an asset class. It allows organisations to gain advantage, and create a moat from their competitors. Compute is an asset.

By substituting compute for money (another asset class), Altman is trying to substitute compute for currency more broadly.

And who creates currency?

Typically, the state. Who now creates currency, sorry I mean compute? The MAANGs that have taken the place of the state.

Compute is currency.

Replacing currency with compute is a form of wrestling control from the state.

As we say in Australia, yeah, nah.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@danstowell Interesting perspective, thank you!

KathyReid, to FiberArts
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

This is incredible - Tracey Clement, a lecturer at , used to visualise the devastating in Australia.

Her work is rage expressed in thread, each stitch a jibe at the people who continue to vacillate in the face of a climate emergency.

Incredible.

https://theconversation.com/15-000-squares-500-hours-19-months-how-i-used-embroidery-to-make-sense-of-australias-catastrophic-fires-227907

Unixbigot, to random
@Unixbigot@aus.social avatar

Venture Capital is dynamite fishing. You sprinkle some “free service” on the waters until you have a nice thick shoal of users. Then you detonate.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@Unixbigot we should call it Vulture Capital

KathyReid, to random
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

In the most glorious "fuck you" I have seen in a while, you know the book that Cumberland City Council banned because they're homophobic bigots - Holly Duhig's "A focus on Same Sex Parents"? Well, the publisher, BookLife Publishing, have made a PDF version of the book available for free.

Sure be a shame if it was shared far and wide now, wouldn't it?

Every time you ban a book filled with hope and kindness, and care and love, we will resist.

https://www.booklifepublishing.co.uk/a-focus-on/same-sex-parents/

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@crone beautifully put!

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar
KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar
KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@Snowshadow ❤️

DanielEriksson, to random
@DanielEriksson@mstdn.science avatar

@KathyReid
Small world - I've students at the ANU Research School of Biology (Williams lab, structural biology of plant innate immunity).

Seems I'll need to explore more of the campus next time I'm in Canberra!

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar
KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@DanielEriksson Ah sorry I saw the flag and assumed Sweden! I am just down the road in Geelong :D

KathyReid, to stackoverflow
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

Like many other technologists, I gave my time and expertise for free to #StackOverflow because the content was licensed CC-BY-SA - meaning that it was a public good. It brought me joy to help people figure out why their #ASR code wasn't working, or assist with a #CUDA bug.

Now that a deal has been struck with #OpenAI to scrape all the questions and answers in Stack Overflow, to train #GenerativeAI models, like #LLMs, without attribution to authors (as required under the CC-BY-SA license under which Stack Overflow content is licensed), to be sold back to us (the SA clause requires derivative works to be shared under the same license), I have issued a Data Deletion request to Stack Overflow to disassociate my username from my Stack Overflow username, and am closing my account, just like I did with Reddit, Inc.

https://policies.stackoverflow.co/data-request/

The data I helped create is going to be bundled in an #LLM and sold back to me.

In a single move, Stack Overflow has alienated its community - which is also its main source of competitive advantage, in exchange for token lucre.

Stack Exchange, Stack Overflow's former instantiation, used to fulfill a psychological contract - help others out when you can, for the expectation that others may in turn assist you in the future. Now it's not an exchange, it's #enshittification.

Programmers now join artists and copywriters, whose works have been snaffled up to create #GenAI solutions.

The silver lining I see is that once OpenAI creates LLMs that generate code - like Microsoft has done with Copilot on GitHub - where will they go to get help with the bugs that the generative AI models introduce, particularly, given the recent GitClear report, of the "downward pressure on code quality" caused by these tools?

While this is just one more example of #enshittification, it's also a salient lesson for #DevRel folks - if your community is your source of advantage, don't upset them.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@LLS @blogdiva Right, so this comes down to the definition of creativity.

If a person re-mixes content in a new or unique way, we consider that creative. Possibly derivative, but creative.

If an LLM does it, is it still creative?

I would argue no, because I see LLMs as bullshit generators that regurgitate what they were fed on, but others are likely to take a different philosophical view.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@njsg that is a good point, so there may also be copyright violations here.

KathyReid, to stackoverflow
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

I just issued a data deletion request to #StackOverflow to erase all of the associations between my name and the questions, answers and comments I have on the platform.

One of the key ways in which #RAG works to supplement #LLMs is based on proven associations. Higher ranked Stack Overflow members' answers will carry more weight in any #LLM that is produced.

By asking for my name to be disassociated from the textual data, it removes a semantic relationship that is helpful for determining which tokens of text to use in an #LLM.

If you sell out your user base without consultation, expect a backlash.

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@arestelle @kellogh excellent points

KathyReid,
@KathyReid@aus.social avatar

@sean Good questions. The way I see a RAG being constructed / or other knowledge graph would be to associate Contributors with Questions and Answers - so you need the Question Answer relationship to generate plausible answers, but the Contributor Answer relationship lets you rank Answers higher from higher rated contributors:

See something like this:
He, Xiaoxin, Yijun Tian, Yifei Sun, Nitesh V. Chawla, Thomas Laurent, Yann LeCun, Xavier Bresson, and Bryan Hooi. "G-Retriever: Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Textual Graph Understanding and Question Answering." arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.07630 (2024).

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • megavids
  • kavyap
  • DreamBathrooms
  • thenastyranch
  • magazineikmin
  • InstantRegret
  • GTA5RPClips
  • Youngstown
  • everett
  • slotface
  • rosin
  • osvaldo12
  • mdbf
  • ngwrru68w68
  • JUstTest
  • cubers
  • modclub
  • normalnudes
  • tester
  • khanakhh
  • Durango
  • ethstaker
  • tacticalgear
  • Leos
  • provamag3
  • anitta
  • cisconetworking
  • lostlight
  • All magazines