Biden pushes new student loan repayment plan as bills loom for tens of millions

President Joe Biden on Tuesday launched a promotional blitz for his new program that helps student loan borrowers repay their debt, just weeks before millions of Americans are set to receive a loan bill for the first time since the beginning of the pandemic.

The Biden administration is mobilizing to convince borrowers across the country to sign up for the new income-driven repayment program — dubbed the “SAVE plan” — which caps interest accrual and lowers the monthly payment amount for many borrowers.

“It’s the most affordable student loan plan ever,” Biden said in a video released by the White House on Tuesday, describing the program as a major reform to a student loan system “that hurt borrowers for much too long.”

“If you’re eligible for the SAVE Plan, sign up now so you can lower your monthly payments in advance of payments resuming this fall,” Biden said.

LuckyCat,

My payments went from ~ $350 to $29 a month. This is such a relief.

K1nsey6,
@K1nsey6@lemmy.world avatar

No one actually thought that the guy who exempted student debt from bankruptcy and is owned by the same billionaires that own Republicans was gonna do what he said?

jeffw,

Not sure what you’re referring to. His student loan forgiveness was blocked by SCOTUS

silentknyght,

Unfortunately, this new plan seems like it’ll increase my payments from about $200/mo to over $900/mo. The calculator says the $900/mo plan comes with an offer of $0 in forgiveness (and says so directly). Even if I keep the $200/mo plan and won’t be fully paid off until 2046 or something (vs 2027 at $900/mo), it still offers me $0 in forgiveness.

I still have $36k in loans and have been paying them off since 2005. I’ve already paid more than I’ve owed, due to interest. I used to be poor, but not really anymore; that kinda happens over 20 years. I suppose I can be happy everyone else, but this doesn’t mean squat for folks like me.

jeffw,

That’s weird. In reading the specifics of the plan, I don’t see how the math would work out towards increasing payments. Unless your income changes significantly, there isn’t really a provision that would increase payments here. It’s designed to drive down interest for all

RagingRobot,

If his income now is more than it was when he set up his first income based repayment plan I think It would go up. I would expect that to be the case for most people because over time salaries go up

silentknyght,

I was never on an income-based repayment plan. I was always on the standard plan. The Internet was really different in 2005, and the info available at my fingertips was much, much less than now. I don’t even know if it was an option, then.

jeffw,

It should be updated with each tax filing though

Javi_in_4k,

How did you figure this out? I’m trying to figure out if it’s worth me applying for it.

silentknyght,

I received an email from studentaid.gov inviting me to apply. It points to a calculator—really a screening-level application—on their site I can use to compare before applying.

bedo6776,

The plan would decrease my payments by about $20/mo and would increase the total amount I would pay. Doesn’t seem like it saves me anything. I’m better off continuing to pay my previous minimum payment and pay the loans off early.

I wish they would eliminate/lower the interest rate.

shottymcb,

It eliminates my wife’s payments entirely with no interest accruing. Which is great because we’re dirt poor at the moment.

Cryophilia,

Which, if I understand correctly, is WHY it eliminated them.

sturmblast,

the current brand new super great SAVE repayment plan that I have access to literally increases my payment by $100 a month

Cryophilia,

Were you able to refuse the new plan and keep your old one? I’d like to check it out to see if my interest rate goes down, but I don’t want to get locked into super high payments.

ZombieTheZombieCat,

How does that work

Krauerking,

Honestly whatever on the whole repayment thing cause I’m poor and fucked no matter what so… Meh.

But seriously can we fucking stop pretending the poverty line is real or even close to where they say it is? When every single benefits package and plan talks about a 200% increase from base poverty line or $20,000 over the base poverty limit for approval it just means poverty is much more common and a lot more expensive than we want to admit but it would freak out hundreds of thousands to realize just how poor they actually are.

Rip off the bandaid of bullshit poverty line adjustments and just be honest that the average American is low class now.

billiam0202,

Yeah, the “temporarily embarrassed millionaires” probably don’t want to know how embarrassed they actually are, or how permanent “temporarily” is.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

unpopular opinion: if you take out a loan, you should have to repay it in full - alternately, dont buy what you cant afford to.

RagnarokOnline,

dont buy what you can’t afford to.

I think this part is what everyone takes exception to. Especially in gen x, no one warned us that “Maybe college isn’t for you because you won’t want a payment that takes 15% of all of your income each month when you’re also trying to scrounge up enough money to buy a house”.

The message was more “you’re going to be begging groceries at Piggly Wiggly like your cousin Bert if you don’t get a degree in something”

Bert now has more in his 401k than I’m even close to. Feels like we’ve been bamboozled.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

I suppose then it’s a lesson on whom you should trust when you’re planning on making life-altering financial decisions. presumably the lesson was learned?

xerazal,

Not just gen x. Millennial here, and I remember college being pushed on us as an idea in middle school up to high school graduation as a “make or break” thing for our futures. You either go to college or you end up a deadbeat.

Bamboozled we definitely were.

BURN,

Top end of Gen Z here (graduated HS in 2017) and it’s the same here. College was the only option presented. Everything else was an alternative to college, not a standalone thing and was also still extremely expensive.

LordR,

Let's start with those huge PPP loans then.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

PPP loans were provided to businesses so that their employees werent immediately fired wholesale - which is what would have happened to many businesses when the customer base dried up during lockdown/covid. businesses are a net gain to the economy - they provide economic stimulus. allowing businesses to fail would just start a collapse. PPP loans by the government worked to prevent that - rather well, in fact.

students eventually provide economic stimulus but are a net detriment until they are capable of adding back to the economy & that includes paying off their student loans.

LordR,

unpopular opinion: if you take out a loan, you should have to repay it in full - alternately, dont buy what you cant afford to.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

and again, students are an economic sink until they’re able to contribute to the economy. conversely, a business will always contribute to the economy - even a failing business pays their employees (or doesnt and the DoL sues them, then pays the employees).

PPP loans were a stopgap measure to ensure that the economy didnt collapse when old people were dying in droves. literally all it was. PPP loans were forgiven because the national economy requires that businesses move money around - the “spice must flow”, if you will - and rightly so, because a business is useful, whereas students really arent.

LordR,

You do realise that most people that have student loans controbute to the economy already because they work after studying for a short time?

Those people can often barely afford to live because the companies that got PPP loans do not pay them a living wage. Those people can't afford buying things which in fact is the only the only way that an economy works.
Without consumption the economy crashes.

Additionally the PPP loans didn't have any oversight. Many business owners used them to buy a new car, a Yacht or other luxuries.
Do you think it is fair to forgive loans for the rich but not the poor?

SexyTimeSasquatch,

As someone who has paid off my own students loans I gotta say I fully disagree. The system we have for paying for college is super predatory and creates incentives for all kinds of shitty, but still legal, behavior by colleges, loan companies, etc. School shouldn’t cost so damn much in the first place, it didn’t for our parents, it shouldn’t have for us, it damn well shouldn’t for our kids.

Cryophilia,

Yeah, and student loan forgiveness doesn’t change that at all, except possibly making it even worse by inflating future tuition costs.

SexyTimeSasquatch,

You’re right, it isn’t sufficient to fix the problem but you can’t make it right without forgiveness for those stuck eternally with the bullshit loans they were coerced into.

Cryophilia,

It’s cart before the horse though. That shouldn’t be the priority.

SexyTimeSasquatch,

Much easier to do though.

Cryophilia,

But then if we do that, all the middle income energy will evaporate. It will become the classic “fuck you, I got mine”. One time relief for millenials and nothing for zoomers?

In the whole time this has been part of the national discussion, I have literally - literally - never ONCE had a loan forgiveness supporter bring up systemic reform. Not even as an AFTERTHOUGHT. Y’all don’t care. You’re not about improving society. You just want your money.

SexyTimeSasquatch,

I literally paid my debt. I’m not in this for money. They got my money. Does it fix all problems? No. Does it help the current massive buildup of debt that is clogging this generations ability to thrive economically? Absolutely. Do we need systemic solutions? For sure. Forgiveness of these loans is good even by itself.

Cryophilia,

I disagree. It’s a handout for a lucky few, and it’s making it worse for everyone else.

Now I’m not against the handout per se. Millenials were definitely shafted and deserve some recompense.

But systemic solutions should be paramount. Harness this anger to fix the problem for everyone.

HellAwaits,

I agree. Let’s start by clawing back all of the forgiven PPE loans that virtually zero people whined and bitched about.

Until then, I don’t want to hear anything about stupid unpopular opinions about student loans.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

ah, you’re looking for an echo chamber then? lol nope. I’m here to rock the boat, pal.

Cryophilia,

I’m against student loan forgiveness, and I think this is a perfectly fair idea.

Fuck free government money to those who don’t need it. That includes the “small business owners” who scammed the fuck out of PPP loans as well as middle class people who benefited from their degree and can afford to pay it back.

xerazal,

Hey bud. College educated here. And that degree has done jack shit for me to get into the field of cloud computing. Just a weight I carry now because every cloud job tells me “oh you have the degree? That’s cool but that degree just means you know the basics. Get x y and z certs. Btw you have to pay for them yourself. And on top of that we want 3-5 years of experience in the field as well. So see you in 2030!”

Cryophilia,

Great. So you’ll get the certs and then you’ll be making 180k and you’ll be able to afford your loans.

transientDCer,

This is a multi layered problem without an easy solution. At face value, there really isn’t anything wrong with your statement, but once you dive into student loans/college education/how public education made everyone believe the only path forward was college - maybe, just maybe something needs to be done.

Capping interest rates so that people can actually pay their debt down is not a bad thing. The root of the problem still needs to be tackled - college is too expensive and administration departments are too bloated - but when the government guarantees the loans, colleges just raise rates because they know students can get them. Schools are not teaching enough financial literacy to make sure kids understand the opportunity cost of what they are signing up for.

Saying this as a person lived at home and commuted to undergrad and for my master’s degree and paid my loan back.

Uranium3006,
Uranium3006 avatar

if it's a loan, it should be dischargable in bankruptcy

chrischryse,

Schools shouldn’t over charge for classes. My university charged 3k for just two courses that were two days a week. School should be cheaper and jobs should pay more.

I wasn’t fortunate enough to have a college fund setup for me or be taught how to save at a very young age. I don’t have parents to put me through college since.

Also why did PPO loans get forgiven? Student loan forgiveness should take priority over that

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

that’s nonsense. higher education has a LOT of administrative overhead. the overwhelming vast majority of teachers/professors/etc expect to make a decent wage. tenure has some impact on that as well, but they sure as hell arent philanthropists - the overall academic experience would be drastically different if educational professionals were not adequately compensated for their work. there are many other factors at play as well but paying the teachers is a big one.

bottom line - education is expensive & will always remain so. accreditation from cheaper schools is all well and good but for many professions, where you graduated from is just as important as the act of obtaining a degree at all.

in regards to “jobs paying more” - a basic job is going to pay whatever is the lowest it can get away with. if it’s too low, no one will accept that job offering & the position will either remain unfilled or the business will offer a higher remuneration. if you lack marketable skills, you are perfectly able to apply for anything you’d like but the chance of you actually gaining that job is laughably low; however, to gain skills one must accrue them - by either working up the ladder, gaining skill via experience, or investment into higher education (which, should be noted doesnt really provide skills, so much as a skillset or framework that the skills can later be integrated into).

PPO has to do with health insurance. not sure what you’re referring to

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Opinion that I don’t care about the popularity of: An educated populace improves the economy and college should be free.

tallwookie,
@tallwookie@lemmy.world avatar

there’s no real guarantee that higher education will lead to a net gain in the economy though - it might, but it’s not a 100% chance.

k-12 is already free, and a lot of people over the decades have been very productive with just that level of education - daresay they’ve contributed more to the economy - after all, anyone working is a net economic gain over no one working, regardless of their level of education.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Good luck getting a job paying much more than $15 an hour without a college degree. That’ll sure make a big economic gain.

wrath-sedan, (edited )
wrath-sedan avatar

This article doesn’t really say what the SAVE plan does so I’m reposting this here.

…the SAVE plan is coming in July 2024 to replace REPAYE, with some parts rolling out this summer and all the details here.

The department says that under the old plan, borrowers repaid $10,956 for every $10,000 they borrowed. Under the new plan, they would pay back just $6,121.

It’s more technical than direct forgiveness but will change income-based plans in the following ways according to this NPR article:

Starting Summer 2023:

  • floor for protected income rising from 150% to 225% of poverty line
  • no interest while payments are being made

Starting Summer 2024:

  • payments now based on 5% rather than 10% of borrowers’ remaining income
  • those who borrow $12,000 or less can gain full forgiveness in 10 years rather than 20 (with each additional $1000 adding another year so $13,000=11 years etc.)

It’s a start, hopefully someone sees this and saves some money.

Also want to add that these changes are not subject to Congressional approval. They could be repealed (impossible with a Dem Senate + Presidential veto) or they could be struck down by SCOTUS, but this is all being performed via powers given by the Higher Education Act and are generally on much firmer legal ground than the loan forgiveness plan SCOTUS scuttled.

Sanity_in_Moderation,

No interest while payments are being made is absolutely gigantic. It’s really a game changer.

Cryophilia,

My payments are already rock bottom but it’s the lower interest that I’m (heh) interested in.

Mikey_donuts,

Just applied tonight and looks like it should reduce my payment by about 50%.

Jackolantern,

Oh man that’s great! This is not the complete loan forgiveness I had hoped for but it’s a start and I hope lots more benefit from this especially the ones who needed it the most.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

I’m so happy for you! I’m going to see if we can bring down my wife’s grad school loan payments. They may not apply.

Mikey_donuts,

Thank you! My loans are from law school and they qualified so definitely give it a shot. Good luck to you and your wife!

cyd,

This is (i) welfare for the well-to-do, (ii) great incentive for colleges to keep pushing up their tuition fees, and (iii) fiscal stimulus during a critical juncture in the fight to tame inflation. Let it not be said that the Republican Party has a monopoly on bad policy ideas.

Coffeemonkepants,

Not sure how you decided this seeing as this benefits people at the poverty line and not the wealthy. Sure, anything can encourage schools to push up tuition prices, but there’s literally a bill in play right now to cap tuition prices. It’s not loan forgiveness, but it’s far better than nothing. Also, the financial impact is a pittance. It’s not the 50k per borrower floated in 2020. It’s not even the 10k the scotus shot down.

Trexman,

Maybe all those well to do folks who cashed government checks and took no-repayment-necessary PPP loans during Covid can pay them back.

Cryophilia,

Them too. Fuck those guys.

Uranium3006,
Uranium3006 avatar

we can also tax big busniess

Wrench,

Ah yes, student loans are all the rage down at the country club. Won’t you be a good chap and bring me my balance statement, of which I will light my Cuban with.

SCB,

People with college degrees, on average, make a million more lifetime dollars than people without. This goes up further with post-graduate education.

Student loan forgiveness should always irst be targeted at college dropouts. Tiering it based on income is not. AS good but is a close 2nd

Semi-Hemi-Demigod,
Semi-Hemi-Demigod avatar

You’re wrong about (i) and (iii) - seriously who does that? - but as someone whose kids will be starting college in a few years I agree with (ii).

We need to find a way to get everyone who is capable a college education without needing loans. Apart from my own personal interests, there is a huge amount of brain power wasted by not having education freely available.

Cryophilia,

You’re wrong about (i) and (iii) - seriously who does that?

I’m confused. Are you saying this is not welfare for the well to do, and is not a form of stimulus?

Semi-Hemi-Demigod,
Semi-Hemi-Demigod avatar

Welfare is not inherently bad.

Not everyone who has student loans is well to do.

This doesn't come into effect until next year, at which time inflation should be under control.

Cryophilia,

That’s fair.

thecodemonk,

Explain how you came up with point one. The well to do will not qualify or benefit from this at all. Its based on income and is definitely skewed to benefit well off people at all.

cyd, (edited )

College graduates receive a big wage premium; over a lifetime, average earnings of graduates exceed those of nongraduates by about $1M. Yes, people who just graduated may not be earning high incomes today, but project things out over decades and it’s clear this is not the group in need of support.

In fact, given the magic of compound interest, we would expect a college loan forgiveness programme to greatly increase the net financial position of graduates versus nongraduates, on top of what the graduate earnings premium already achieves. Hence increasing the overall level of wealth inequality in the country.

ImFresh3x,

I disagree with you, but your position has some sentiments I can understand. So instead of getting angry, downvoting, and throwing a fit, I am just going to respond calmly:

If you look at the actual details of the plan it’s pretty reasonable.

Lowered interest rates for everyone who are making their payments.

Higher threshold for low income earners to get some forgiveness. This counters your “well-to-do” argument.

Cryophilia,

I think he was referring to the idea of forgiveness, not this plan.

ImFresh3x,

Well this plan is the topic. Or so I thought.

Cryophilia,

Not exclusively, no. There’s a lot of discussion about the original forgiveness plan too, the one struck down by the courts.

ImFresh3x,

Ya but it’s was an OP comment. Response to the new plan in that context.

I could see if he was responding to a comment that was about a different plan from before. But it was an un truncated comment that responds to the article.

Cryophilia,

You’re right, if we follow the flow of the conversation it looks like he’s talking about this plan. I assumed he was talking about full forgiveness since his criticisms don’t make sense otherwise, but maybe he just has fox news brain rot.

ImFresh3x,

You’re right too.

Maybe or maybe not Fox News brain rot. Maybe just addressing the greater discussion of the past times as you said. But I assumed in this context otherwise. There’s a lot of people who don’t read articles and just talk in very broad terms.

cazsiel,

I’m well to do now? This is for me and I consider not eating for 48 hours at a time because the price of food rn is bonkers to be a solid financial decision.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

My parents were/are (Mom’s still alive) well-to-do. I was lucky in that I didn’t have to take out student loans. No one is giving me welfare.

My wife, on the other hand, could sure use some relief from the student loan debt she incurred because her family is not the privileged one mine is.

We’re fiscally responsible. We pay our bills on time. We have a fixed-rate mortgage. We have two cars, but one is paid off.

We’re in our mid-40s and she still has a ton of student loan debt. That’s insanity.

SCB,

Sounds like you have plenty of money but only pay the minimum payments on her loans, which is a questionable choice at best.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

It may sound like that, but that would be false. We live paycheck-to-paycheck like a majority of Americans.

We pay what we can afford to pay.

Believe it or not, people who grow up with wealthy parents aren’t necessarily wealthy themselves.

Cryophilia,

Dude you have a mortgage. You are not paycheck to paycheck, you have assets you can pull equity from at any time. You may not be saving cash but you are saving assets.

You are not poor.

Let me say that again.

YOU ARE NOT POOR.

Tired of all these upper middle class people pretending like they’re lining up at food banks. You’re good, dude. You made it. You are doing better than most. You don’t need relief. You know who needs relief? The dude who never had the opportunity to go to college in the first place and is making $20,000 a year.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

I never said I was poor. But going into more debt would make us poor.

I’m certainly not upper middle class.

Cryophilia,

If you can afford to get a mortgage on a house nowadays, you are upper middle class.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Nowadays? We bought it 10 years ago. In a depressed small city with high unemployment. It’s also only worth about $200,000. You know how low that is for a house right now?

Maybe don’t make assumptions.

Cryophilia,

How much was it worth when you bought it?

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

$175,000. So clearly it’s a luxury mansion. Jesus fucking Christ.

Cryophilia,

Liar. There’s practically no markets in the country that have seen such low appreciation over 10 years. That doesn’t even match inflation.

Either you’re stupendously unlucky (in which case my point still stands) or you’re a liar (more likely, and again my point still stands).

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Oh fuck off. You have no idea. I’m not lucky or a liar, but you’re fucking blocked.

Cryophilia,

Hahaha caught you out, did I?

CryptoRoberto,

Saw an article earlier today that over 60% of borrowers are planning to boycott repayment. I still haven’t setup an account since my loan got transferred to a new servicer. Seriously considering making them come garnish my wages or something. If enough people do it, the system will almost certainly collapse. I can’t imagine all the servicers trying to go through the garnishment process with that many people.

Wrench,

That… seems like a self destructive plan that will only accomplish ruining your credit score for 7 years

CryptoRoberto,

Own a home, have a pretty new car, don’t plan on moving anytime soon. Could come up with enough cash to pay for anything I need pretty easily and already have lots of established credit. I’m older and stable.

Wrench,

You sound like the kind of person that has benefited from a degree and can pay your debt

CryptoRoberto,

Yup, i can. Its almost like I’d be joining in as a form of protest for those who can’t. Weird to have solidarity and sympathy for others right?

Wrench,

I don’t see that as helping anyone. You’re protesting from a point of privilege. Those that aren’t can be seriously financially harmed by following your example.

It’s like throwing the first stone at a peaceful protest when your daddy is powerful and can get you out of consequences.

CryptoRoberto,

Gee, we should all just sit on our hands and piss our pants for progress. It gets more done. How did I not see this before.

BraveSirZaphod,
BraveSirZaphod avatar

Personally, if I loaned someone a thousand dollars, they were perfectly capable of paying me back, but said that they would be withholding the payment out of solidarity, I'd be rather annoyed.

But hey, if you wanna publicly announce to lenders that your word is meaningless, that's your call. Certainly hope you don't wind up in an unexpected bind.

Also, chasing payment from delinquent debtors is a cost that simply gets shifted on to everyone else in the form of higher interest rates on the people who actually are honest, so you're not doing the poor the service you think you are.

ZombieTheZombieCat,

We’re really caring about student loan servicers’ feelings? Like Nelnet? If that’s what they want to do, then it does show solidarity regardless of how privileged they may be.

Zuberi,
@Zuberi@lemmy.dbzer0.com avatar

Bootlicker

BraveSirZaphod,
BraveSirZaphod avatar

Freeloader.

See, I can toss out meaningless one-word insults without making any actual points too. I hope it was as much fun for you as it was for me.

Zuberi,
@Zuberi@lemmy.dbzer0.com avatar

Says the kid sucking billionaire dick for breakfast

BraveSirZaphod,
BraveSirZaphod avatar

I am shocked that the edgelord is also a homophobe, truly.

Zuberi,
@Zuberi@lemmy.dbzer0.com avatar

Any orientation can suck dick, I’m just hoping you’re a cis-man like you portray

ZombiFrancis,

Yes but if we are pretending: now pretend you’re a government that provides services to its citizens. As in, making profit from interest of education loans is counterproductive and undermines the purpose of getting citizens educated.

BraveSirZaphod,
BraveSirZaphod avatar

From what I saw, briefly looking around, the interest rate is a fair bit lower for government loans than private ones, and when you add in inflation and administrative costs, I could imagine the actual profit margin on public loans being relatively low. Regardless though, I strongly agree with the fundamental point that investments in education are generally a really good use of government money.

That said, subsidizing demand like that does give universities a lot of leeway to dramatically increase costs (as well as giving state governments cover to slash funding to state universities). Additionally, given that university graduates go on to make quite a lot more money than non-grads - even if the first several years out can be a bit rough dealing with loan payments - throwing them even more money isn't exactly the most progressive use of tax funds if you're aiming to help the poor. I'd much much rather graduates who are actually able to re-pay their loans, even if it involves a bit of belt-tightening for a bit, to do that so that that money can be used to help fund education costs for more people who truly need it. The median student loan debt is about the same as the median cost of attending a public university for one year, so every person that decides to just not pay their debt back is one less student in true need of assistance that won't be able to go to college. It's more than reasonable for people who benefited from loans to help fund the next wave of students, and doing so makes the financials much much more scalable and sustainable.

ZombiFrancis,

I think there is an obscured part of the student loan debate were federal loans were never really quite enough to fund college alone. Rising tuitions have meant a private loan becomes a basic necessity for covering the costs unless you have something like generational wealth, or specific subsidy like a scholarship.

It’s created a feedback loop where students are funneled increasingly towards taking on private loans to complete their degree, or have to drop out and have all the debt for nothing. To the point one could argue people aren’t benefitting from the loans to begin with.

Cryophilia,

Subsidizing without regulation just raises costs.

Zuberi,
@Zuberi@lemmy.dbzer0.com avatar

Why regulate banks when we can regulate the poors /s

Stupid take is stupid.

“Profit margin on public loans being relatively low” made me die of laughter

snipvoid,

So much for slashing the debt altogether, eh? An excellent production.

Telodzrum,

Tell me you haven’t been paying attention at all without telling me you haven’t been paying attention at all.

snipvoid, (edited )

Paying attention to what?

Oh you mean this:

Biden again rejects $50,000 student loan debt forgiveness plan

It’s really hard to keep track of all the debts Americans have.

Dr_Cog,
@Dr_Cog@mander.xyz avatar

Dude that was 2 years ago

Alto,
Alto avatar

But that doesn't go with the narrative!

snipvoid,

BINDENOMOMICS SAVES THE FLAG

Which narrative is that?

snipvoid,

And you still only got $20k.

Why not 40k?

Dr_Cog,
@Dr_Cog@mander.xyz avatar

Because Republicans blocked the debt relief, nobody got 20k. You really haven’t been paying attention, have you?

Cryophilia,

Hard to pay attention when you have to worry about Ukranian drones because you’re a fascist tool

Dr_Cog,
@Dr_Cog@mander.xyz avatar

Russia: attacks Ukraine

Ukraine: attacks back

Tankies: wow, I can’t believe Ukraine would do this

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

That’s great. Remember this? scotusblog.com/…/supreme-court-strikes-down-biden…

Do tell us how that’s Biden’s fault.

snipvoid,

I sure do! Who said anything about Biden’s fault?

It’s your fault, and your peers.

Or perhaps you can tell me why you’ve decided that you’re happy living your life in crippling debt, desperately crossing your fingers for the branches of government to decide that they’ll finally afford you the very smallest crumbs of relief possible.

How much above the FDIC insurance threshold of $250,000 did the individual accounts of Silicon Valley Bank get bailed out for again?

Oh, and how much has been recovered for the $100+ billion balance of PPP loan fraud?

Curious.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

How is it my fault? What exactly was I supposed to do?

snipvoid,

What have people historically done when their government exists for the benefit of the aristocracy/oligarchs/billionaires while the people suffer, starve, and drown in poverty?

ZombieTheZombieCat,

Proletariat revolution only works when all or most people are on board. One or a few people doing it will just land them in jail basically. This system is structured so that if we do something like that, we will be on the street within a month or two and not be able to care for our families. Please don’t make assumptions about the situations that millions of Americans are trapped in. Especially if it is not something you’ve lived under yourself, or aren’t formally educated in. They don’t call it “manufactured consent” for nothing. We’re born into it and we have to participate in it if we want to survive. Literally.

snipvoid, (edited )

Your assertion about the need for unanimous backing in a proletariat revolution is laughably simplistic. And I’ll kindly ask you to refrain from making assumptions about my own lived experiences, or anyone else’s for that matter.

Every revolution, every major movement in history, started with the bold few before swelling into unstoppable masses. Afraid of landing in jail? Understandable. But jail cells have a way of creating symbols that ignite larger flames. Ask yourself: can they really jail us all? Every filled cell will magnify our cause, not quell it.

As for the dire consequences you highlight, like ending up on the streets, let’s be clear: many are already there, with or without revolution. They’ve little left to lose and much to gain. And the belief that we’re just trying to care for our families under the current system? It’s doing a disservice to those already struggling, trying to protect their loved ones in a world that has been designed against them.

You mentioned “manufactured consent,” and that’s spot on. But think deeper: it’s manufactured. Crafted. Made to fit. And anything constructed can be deconstructed, redesigned, or outright obliterated. We aren’t simply passive recipients of this design; we’re conditioned to believe it’s the only one.

So while you’re trapped in a narrative of inevitability and compliance, I see potential. Potential in every oppressed individual who’s been underestimated. Strength. Resistance. Evolution. Life has schooled me in the harshest of ways, and I assure you, the lessons stick. We’re not just passively surviving this broken system; we’re actively challenging, adapting, and overcoming.

Remember, the heart of humanity isn’t so easily suppressed. Before you use words like “literally” again, reflect on this: maybe the real illusion is thinking we’re helpless in the face of the chains society has slapped on us.

I’ll leave you with bell hooks: There is an element of play in choice, an exercise of free will. One chooses to live through consciousness, aware and awakened.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Sorry, was supposed to personally go and assassinate Biden? That’s what you’re saying I was supposed to do?

snipvoid,

Is that question wilful ignorance, or just regular ignorance?

Nice try, but no, your fantasy option is a non-starter: it wouldn’t accomplish an end to your suffering.

Keep thinking. I have faith in you.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Sorry, “keep thinking” doesn’t explain what you meant if that’s not what you meant.

I can’t read your mind.

snipvoid,

I’m happy to hold your hand.

Let’s begin!

What do you think would accomplish an end to the suffering you feel every day as a consequence of living in America? Fantasy or reasonable.

Just go with your gut.

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

I still have no idea what you’re talking about. If you’re not going to explain yourself, forget it. I’m not interested in playing silly games.

snipvoid,

Enjoy the debt babes <3

Daft_ish,

He mad.

givesomefucks,

It’s still not thru congress yet, and the part Biden brags about wouldn’t even start till next summer…

I’ll be surprised if any of it materializes, but that won’t stop moderates from bragging about it.

jeffw,

You can literally apply now. It doesn’t need to go through Congress

givesomefucks,

You should read an article if you’re going to post it…

Not even getting to the point that people were encouraged to apply for forgiveness and that never happened.

BassTurd,

Why didn’t it happen again? Oh yea. It’s because Republicans hate Americans and blocked it. Such a worthless group of people.

CryptoRoberto,

But also, they could of passed a fucking bill when they had a majority…

BassTurd,

Please tell me when it was that the Biden administration had control of both the House and Senate and could have pushed it through.

CryptoRoberto,

You don’t remember when they said we’d all get $2,000 checks (which was bullshit) and that they’d have control of the Senate? For like 30 while seconds after the Georgia runoffs they pretended Sinema and Manchin were actual Democrats. Good thing the Democrats are so good at vetting and controlling their party members.

Slightly better walking corpse 2024! Woooooooo

FlyingSquid,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Sorry… how were Democrats supposed to control who people in West Virginia and Arizona elected exactly?

And what sort of Democrat do you think it’s possible to elect in West Virginia?

CryptoRoberto,

It’s almost like a powerful political group has a lot of influence on who gets to be part of said party and wins the primaries. Or they can eat shit sandwiches and ride tricycles around the circus tent and be an unadulterated clown show. It’s a good thing they never put their fingers on the scale unless the mega donors like Goldman Sachs wants someone though. Gotta keep it cash money up in the corporate housing.

jeffw,

I did read it. Did you lol?

HWK_290,

Oh ok, guess we should give up then and succumb to our corporate overlords

Cryophilia,

Even better, vote Republican! That will solve your problems! Somehow! Trust me bro!

  • totally not a Russian shill
Daft_ish,

This is what we call accelerationists. Race to the bottom. Americans suck because they will never realize the rich have no country. They may have investments but that is their only stake. America falls into poverty, no worry for the rich. They still have their fenced yard and private military.

givesomefucks,

Nope.

But I feel like pretending something is done before it is after the last couple years…

Is naive at best.

We keep getting told that things are fixed, and people stop paying attention, then a year down the line it’s still not done.

Don’t start running victory laps at halftime, you’ll just tire yourself out.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • politics@lemmy.world
  • rosin
  • DreamBathrooms
  • Durango
  • magazineikmin
  • InstantRegret
  • ngwrru68w68
  • Youngstown
  • everett
  • slotface
  • tacticalgear
  • cisconetworking
  • khanakhh
  • kavyap
  • thenastyranch
  • megavids
  • vwfavf
  • osvaldo12
  • mdbf
  • modclub
  • GTA5RPClips
  • Leos
  • normalnudes
  • cubers
  • ethstaker
  • tester
  • provamag3
  • anitta
  • JUstTest
  • All magazines
    •